Why the study?
Does the etiology of acute diarrhea differ between children treated as outpatients versus those requiring hospital admission?
Does the etiology of acute diarrhea differ between children treated as outpatients versus those requiring hospital admission?
The similarity of etiological agents between mild and severe acute diarrhea suggests that community enteric illness etiology can be inferred from inpatient data, and severity is likely driven by host susceptibility rather than viral strain differences.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Similar rotavirus strains cause mild and severe diarrhea; leaves open host factors as severity drivers and supports cautious extrapolation from inpatient data.
The etiology of acute diarrhea in children less than 42 months of age attending one pediatric hospital in Melbourne, Australia, was studied during a 7-month period encompassing the winter of 1984. Pathogens identified in 157 children treated as outpatients with mild disease were compared with those in 232 children hospitalized with severe disease. The pathogens (and frequencies among outpatients and inpatients, respectively) detected were rotaviruses (32.5 and 50.9%), enteric adenoviruses (8.9 and 7.4%), Campylobacter jejuni (7.2 and 1.3%), and Salmonella sp. (4.0 and 1.7%). Electropherotypes of rotavirus strains from outpatients and inpatients were compared. Two strains predominated during the 7 months of this study and were observed with equal frequency from outpatients and inpatients. Rotaviruses of the same electropherotype caused a wide spectrum of disease, with symptoms ranging from mild to severe, life-threatening diarrhea. The similarity of etiological agents identified from children with mild and severe forms of acute diarrhea suggests that the etiology of community enteric illness can be reasonably inferred from the etiology of inpatient disease in children in the same geographic area. During the winter epidemic period, the severity of symptoms associated with rotavirus infection in young children is likely to be determined by the inherent susceptibility of the host rather than by genetic differences in the strains of infecting rotaviruses.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Pitson et al. (1986) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: