Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The focal article by Lefkowitz and colleagues (2026) resurfaces a persistent pattern in I-O psychology: Organized labor is treated as marginal to the field's science and practice, even though unions are core institutions in employment relations.That stance is difficult to defend given that the right to organize is widely recognized as a basic human right (United Nations, 1948), and unions remain a central mechanism for improving safety, health, and well-being at work (Carriere, 2020;Vesper et al., 2025).I extend the focal argument by focusing on a mechanism that makes this pattern durable.A field built for management, not labor What many I-O psychologists label as "neutrality" is a product of our field's professionally socialized position that defaults to managerial and corporate interests while also treating power, class, and collective worker voice as "out of scope."Although this enables I-O practices to appear value free, especially in labor-management relations, neutrality is not a middle ground.It's a choice.When we avoid conversations around pay inequity at the C-suite level while simultaneously using people analytics to "optimize" significant layoffs, we do not stay outside the conflict.We stand firmly on one side of it: the organization, not the worker.This is hard to reconcile with frameworks that position decent work and worker rights as psychological and societal imperatives (Blustein et al., 2019) and with calls inside I-O to clarify who the field ultimately serves when interests diverge (Blacksmith & Schmittzehe, 2023).Arthur Kornhauser's (1947) foundational question, "Do we work on the problems of the private businessman, or on the problems of society?" has been answered repeatedly, although implicitly.Thus, the debate is not new.What is new is the field's continued insistence that our choices reflect neutrality rather than values.Neutrality is produced, not found Professional neutrality in I-O psychology is not an absence of values.It is a value system that is learned, reinforced, and rewarded.Graduate training and early career socialization teach students to treat employer-defined problems as the crux of "fixing" the workplace while treating collective worker institutions as political, ideological, or simply irrelevant.Over time, this produces an "apolitical" professional identity that is compatible with employer power and uncomfortable with institutions that explicitly negotiate, contest, or constrain that power.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lora Bishop (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: