Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In their Viewpoints, both Manville, Monkkonen, and Lens (this issue) and Wegmann (this issue) make passionate calls to eliminate single-family zoning altogether. Single-family zoning in the United States has been implicated in reducing the supply of affordable housing and exacerbating inequity and racial segregation, among other ills (Chakraborty, Knaap, Nguyen, & Shin, 2010). Several cities and states, notably Minneapolis (MN) and Oregon, are attempting to address these ills by actively planning a future that will allow multifamily units by right in neighborhoods that presently allow nothing but detached, single-family housing. Many other communities around the nation are considering similar changes, and the moment appears ripe to vigorously question the future of singlefamily zoning in the United States. These questions deserve consideration—and greater scrutiny. Minneapolis and Oregon are bold experiments worthy of attention. And the Viewpoints rightly criticize the traditional arguments for single-family zoning and the biases planners often display toward preserving exclusive single-family neighborhoods. Still, calls for “fullthroated denunciation” (Wegmann, this issue, p. 117) of all single-family zoning should be received with caution given the available evidence and the political context of planning. Let us consider some fundamental questions.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arnab Chakraborty (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: