Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Budgeting has traditionally been the process through which governments decide how much to spend on what, limiting expenditures to the revenues available and preventing overspending. Over time, public budgets have taken on different roles, becoming tools for bargaining and allocating power, for planning and controlling, for providing impulses to the economic and social environment and for ensuring transparency and stakeholder involvement (Saliterer, Sicilia, and Steccolini Forthcoming). As such, budgets play, among others, political, economic, managerial and accountability functions. They perform a political function as they reflect stakeholders’ preferences and power positions, representing the same time the result of past decisions and bargains, and the basis for future discussions. They define the boundaries of public intervention in the economy, and the degree of redistribution of wealth in the economic system, fulfilling an economic function. They are also increasingly used to hold managers accountable for the attainment of results and use of public resources, thus filling a managerial function, and to hold public organizations accountable to the general public, satisfying an external accountability function. The multifaceted nature of budgeting has generally translated into its being the subject of enduring interest by different disciplines, including political science, public administration, accounting, psychology, management and organization studies. At the same time, budgeting is an arena where different rationalities, logics, competencies and professional identities interact. The complexity and variety of functions of budgeting, and its being an arena of interaction of different actors, cultures, professional identities and disciplines probably account for the variety of approaches and forms taken on by budget documents and budgeting processes (Saliterer, Sicilia, and Steccolini Forthcoming) and by its variable nature over time. These same features also contribute to make public budgeting an extremely fascinating field and topic of investigation, which can provide a number of insights on political, social, economic and psychological processes. It may thus represent the ideal setting for bringing in views from different scholarly communities and disciplines to show what can be learnt by accepting that social, political and economic processes are complex and rich arenas, where deterministic and simplistic explanations limit our views and possibilities, and accepting that the challenge of complexity can be risky in the current ‘publish and perish’ culture, but also extremely rewarding and stimulating. This is the challenge that the authors of this special issue accepted to take up, contributing to offer a rich and in-depth view of current trends in the studies and practices of public budgeting at a time when New Public Management (NPM) influence still appears to remain important (Lapsley 2009), but claims have increasingly emerged that either other paradigms may be emerging (e.g., Osborne 2006, 2009), or that we may be witnessing a paradigmatic gap (Coen and Roberts 2012).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sicilia et al. (2016) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: