Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Dry cooling, reclaimed municipal wastewater, brackish water, and produced water are potential options for reducing freshwater use for thermoelectric cooling. However, there are tradeoffs in the technical, economic, environmental, and regulatory dimensions associated with their implementation at existing power plants. This study performs a multi-criteria decision analysis in conjunction with a stakeholder survey to rank these freshwater-saving alternatives under uncertainty. Stakeholders prioritize water environmental impact with a global weight of 0.46, followed by technical feasibility (0.24), economic viability (0.18), and regulatory compliance (0.12). Dry cooling is positioned as the most preferred option, with an 80% likelihood, largely due to its ability to minimize water environmental impact, which is viewed as the most significant criterion. However, deterministic decisions can be biased toward certain outcomes if uncertainties in stakeholder judgments and option performance are not considered. Sensitivity analyses across numerous key factors confirm full preservation of the ranking. However, if either economic viability or technical feasibility is viewed as the most important criterion, reclaimed municipal wastewater is considered the superior solution. Currently, large energy and cost penalties, plus water environmental impact for treating brackish water and produced water, limit their competitiveness in the water-stressed western regions. Accelerating at-scale reuse of non-traditional water sources requires increased R&D investment in advanced desalination technologies.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Arnob et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: