Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mixed-method analysis reveals implicit sociopsychological and cybernetic dominance in listening scholarship, suggesting the need for theoretical cosmopolitanism across communication research.
Theory drives knowledge production in any discipline, but unfortunately the field of listening research and theorization remains largely unorganized. To remedy this disorganization and fill a nearly three-decade narrative gap in the field’s self-evaluation, this article presents a comprehensive metatheoretical mapping of listening scholarship from 1987 to 2025. Utilizing a mixed-method approach that combines qualitative thematic analysis with quantitative semantic analysis, I apply Craig’s communication metamodel to a corpus of 45 theory articles from the community of practice in the International Journal of Listening (IJL). The findings reveal a field characterized by a significant tension: while the sociopsychological and cybernetic traditions dominate the scholarship thematically, they are rarely named semantically. In addition, the rhetorical and critical traditions are frequently cited but rarely utilized as a primary theoretical framework. By identifying these trends and highlighting key moments of cross-tradition dialogue, this analysis situates listening within the broader, more established landscape of communication theory. Ultimately, this article serves as the introduction to a special issue that advocates for a theoretical cosmopolitanism that moves beyond traditional listening theory attempts to ensure a more coherent and innovative future for the field of listening.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Brandon Shanks (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: