Key result
The authors argue that vascular wave reflection significantly contributes to central pressure augmentation, critiquing recent claims that it is principally determined by ventricular systolic function.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This commentary highlights the ongoing debate regarding the relative contributions of wave reflection versus left ventricular systolic function to central pressure augmentation.
Wave reflection and central pressure augmentationRecently, Cheng et al [1] proposed that central pressure augmentation may be principally determined by left ventricular systolic function rather than vascular wave reflection.We would like to make three comments.First, we question Cheng et al's interpretation of published work about the role of wave reflection in pressure augmentation.Specifically, [2] and [3] were cited to suggest that the contribution of reflected waves is small or absent in the aorta, while it was stated that [4] "failed to find evidence supporting any predominant effect of wave reflection on pressure augmentation".However, 1) Manisty et al [2] studied carotid (not aortic) waveforms, reported reflection coefficients of ~0.5 (not small or absent) and stated that "[wave] separation clearly demonstrated that [higher AIx in individuals randomized to atenolol-based rather than amlodipine-based regimen occurred] because of increased wave reflection".It is true that in one example in [2] (Figure 1, right panel), a small forward compression wave labelled 'c + 1' mainly caused the pressure augmentation.Although this wave could conceivably have a direct ventricular origin, it has not been observed in the aorta [5--7] and thus probably arises when reflected waves from elsewhere in the body (e.g. the brachiocephalic artery) are transmitted forwards into the carotid artery [8].2) The conclusion of Davies et al [3] that augmentation index (AIx) is mainly due to changes in reservoir pressure, not wave reflection, was based on a controversial modification of wave intensity analysis, namely the 'reservoir-wave paradigm', which we have recently shown underestimates actual wave reflection by 40-100%[9].Moreover, the view advanced in [3] is moot because, as we [9] and others [10] have pointed out, the reservoir pressure is generated by wave reflection.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Joseph J. Smolich (2013) conducted a letter in Central pressure augmentation. The authors argue that vascular wave reflection significantly contributes to central pressure augmentation, critiquing recent claims that it is principally determined by ventricular systolic function.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: