Why the study?
Do noninvasive cardiac output measurements (thoracic bioimpedance and suprasternal Doppler ultrasound) accurately correlate with thermodilution in clinical patients?
Do noninvasive cardiac output measurements (thoracic bioimpedance and suprasternal Doppler ultrasound) accurately correlate with thermodilution in clinical patients?
Thoracic bioimpedance and suprasternal Doppler ultrasound show moderate overall correlation with thermodilution for measuring cardiac output, with better agreement in specific subgroups such as mechanically ventilated patients without recent cardiac or aortic surgery.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Moderate correlations preclude routine clinical use of these noninvasive monitors; leaves open any subgroup role pending prospective validation.
The authors attempted to simultaneously measure cardiac output by thermodilution (COtd), thoracic bioimpedance (CObi), and suprasternal Doppler ultrasound (COdopp) in 68 patients. Subgroups separately compared included patients whose lungs were mechanically ventilated, patients undergoing cardiac surgery, aortic surgery, patients with dysrhythmias, and patients with sepsis. The authors also studied the value of the ventricular ejection time (VET) in evaluating the agreement of CObi and COdopp with COtd. Simultaneous CObi and COtd were available in a total of 56 patients (416 data sets) with an overall correlation coefficient r = 0.61, regression slope (m) of 0.52, intercept (y) of 2.46, and mean (CObi-COtd) difference (bias) of -0.67 +/- 1.72 (SD) l/min. Simultaneous COdopp and COtd were available in 59 patients (446 data sets) with an overall r = 0.51, m of 0.53, y of 2.05, and bias of -0.79 +/- 1.95 l/min. CObi agreed most closely with COtd in patients whose lungs were mechanically ventilated, who had not undergone cardiac or aortic surgery, and with VET difference less than 40 ms (16 patients, 99 data sets; r = 0.74; m = 0.97; y = 0.15; bias = -0.02 +/- 1.53 l/min). COdopp agreed most closely with COtd in patients whose lungs were mechanically ventilated, who had not undergone cardiac or aortic surgery, and in sinus rhythm with VET difference less than 40 ms (10 patients, 45 data sets; r = 0.82; m = 0.98; y = -0.07; bias = -0.82 +/-1.03 l/min). VET by radial artery can help evaluate the reliability of CObi and COdopp.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wong et al. (1990) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: