Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A 57-year-old patient with analgesic nephropathy, hypertension, hyperlipoproteinemia, and coronary heart disease received his second renal graft in August 2001. His first renal transplant functioned for 9 years and was removed in 1999 because of chronic allograft dysfunction. At the time of the second transplantation, no human leukocyte antigen antibodies were detected. The graft was a four-antigen match and the patient did not develop donor-specific antibodies (DSA). Immunosuppression consisted of steroids, cyclosporine A, and mycophenolate mofetil. A protocol biopsy at 6 weeks (serum creatinine, 186 μmol/L; urine protein, 0.49 g/L) showed mild acute transplant glomerulitis with activated mononuclear cells in glomerular capillary loops, minimal mononuclear cell infiltration in the interstitium, and mild tubulitis consistent with Banff-borderline changes. The endothelium was not perturbed. However, the peritubular capillaries (PTC) were dilated and filled with neutrophils and mononuclear cells. A strong, diffusely positive C4d signal was detected in the PTC by immunohistochemistry, applying a commercially available polyclonal antiserum to the paraffin-embedded biopsy core (Fig. 1). DSA were negative and there were no signs of cytomegalovirus or polyomavirus. At 12 weeks (serum creatinine, 170 μmol/L; urine protein, 0.18 g/L), a second protocol biopsy specimen showed similar findings. Circulating endothelial cells were present at a low level (1). The patient was treated with methylprednisolone, without additional changes. Because we were puzzled by the biopsy findings, we performed a third biopsy at 4.5 months after transplantation (serum creatinine, 149 μmol/L; urine protein, 0.21 g/L) only to be confronted with the same findings by light microscopy. This time, we performed in addition to the C4d stain our routine immunohistochemical panel for kidney biopsies (C1q, C3, immunoglobulin [Ig] A, IgG, IgM, fibrin-fibrinogen) and electron microscopy. The C4d stain yielded the same diffuse staining pattern in the PTC as in the previous biopsy specimens. The glomeruli showed focally a faint positive stain for C1q, C3, and IgG in the mesangium. In addition, C1q was found in the wall of larger arteries. On the electron microscopic examination, glomerular changes consistent with an acute transplant glomerulitis were present, whereas no evidence of chronic transplant glomerulopathy could be detected. Peritubular capillaries were filled with mononuclear cells and neutrophils, whereas their basement membranes were unremarkable. The last protocol biopsy was performed at 6 months (serum creatinine, 130 μmol/L; urine protein, 0.20 g/L). Transplant glomerulitis was still present by light microscopy. The arteries were still unremarkable. On the electron microscopic examination, a segmental basement membrane and mesangial matrix thickening were interpreted as initial changes in the sense of chronic allograft glomerulopathy. Immunohistochemistry for C1q, C3, and IgM revealed a segmentally intense stain in glomerular basement membranes, whereas C3 and IgM were also detectable in the wall of small and larger arteries. In contrast, C4d was now absent. At 18 months after transplantation, the patient remains stable. Currently, the serum creatinine is 124 μmol/L and still virtually no protein excretion (0.03 g/L) is present. Figure 1: Biopsy specimen 6 weeks after transplantation. (A) Acute transplant glomerulitis, mild mononuclear interstitial infiltration, and peritubular capillaries filled with mononuclear cells and neutrophils (arrows) (periodic acid-Schiff stain; magnification × 400). (B) Diffuse positive C4d staining in the peritubular capillaries (ABC technique at paraffin section; magnification × 400).C4d deposition in PTC and morphologic changes consistent with acute humoral rejection occurred in routine protocol biopsy specimens in our patient despite stable allograft function. C4d can be frequently found in glomeruli, arterial intima, and the tubular basement membranes of normal kidneys. However, C4d accumulation in PTC is an accepted specific sign for ongoing humoral rejection and implies a poor clinical outcome (2,3). Pathologic criteria for humoral rejection include C4d deposition in PTC, circulating DSA, and one of the following: neutrophils in the PTC, arterial fibrinoid necrosis, or acute tubular injury (4,5). In any event, 25% of cases with signs of humoral rejection lack diffuse C4d staining. Our patient fulfilled two (C4d-positive, pathologic biopsy findings) of the three criteria for humoral rejection; DSA against human leukocyte antigen remained negative. The negative DSA does not exclude the presence of circulating alloreactive antibodies against endothelium or other structures associated with vascular rejection. In patients with humoral rejection, converting immunosuppression to mycophenolate mofetil and tacrolimus in addition to plasmapheresis has been suggested as an effective therapeutic approach (6). We eschewed this strategy, because the patient was stable. C4d deposition disappeared spontaneously 6 months after renal transplantation. Whether C4d deposition is a definite sign of humoral rejection or endothelial damage of any other genesis or whether C4d merely signifies a nonspecific subclinical self-limited inflammatory state cannot be determined from our data. Because our protocol biopsy specimens showed C4d in PTC and simultaneously corresponding morphologic changes, we would interpret the present case rather as a subclinical episode of acute humoral rejection. However, because the pathogenic role of C4d is not completely understood, further studies are warranted to uncover the true incidence of C4d deposition in all renal allografts, including those that are stable and those exhibiting dysfunction. Furthermore, more information on the mechanisms and consequences of PTC C4d deposition need to be elucidated in terms of guiding therapeutic decisions. Anette Fiebeler1,2 Michael Mengel1 Saskia Merkel1 Hermann Haller1 Anke Schwarz1,3
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fiebeler et al. (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: