Key result
Dark chocolate and coffee show cardiovascular benefits, whereas wine appears at best neutral.
Why the study?
The cardiovascular effects of wine, coffee, and chocolate are complex and require serious consideration to clarify their protective or harmful roles.
Does consumption of wine, chocolate, and coffee improve cardiovascular outcomes in the general population?
Does consumption of wine, chocolate, and coffee improve cardiovascular outcomes in the general population?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This review highlights that while dark chocolate and moderate coffee consumption may offer cardiovascular benefits, the purported protective effects of alcohol are outweighed by its dose-dependent risks.
Cardiovascular effects of wine, coffee, and chocolate: protective effects are shown in green and harmful effects in red colour. DCM, dilated cardiomyopathy. Life is more than work, also for dedicated cardiologists; thus, we enjoy wine, drinks, sweets, and coffee—are these forbidden joys or are they possibly even protective? That is here the question! The answer is more complex than a simple yes or no—so, let us consider the evidence seriously. Intentionally fermented beverages existed as early as the Neolithic age; in a prehistoric burial site in a cave near Haifa, residues of 13 000-year-old beer, apparently used for ritual feasts, was found. At that time, fermentation was the only way to preserve beverages. Today, we still enjoy alcoholic beverages in different forms, although we have lots of means for preservation. We consume the same amount of alcohol with any drink as the glass for beer is the largest, the one for wine is smaller and the smallest is used for spirits. However, the ingredients other than alcohol differ: Wine contains cardioprotective antioxidant flavonoids and resveratrol stimulating the longevity gene SIRT1.1 Beer contains grain, mostly malted barley, but also hops and yeast. Barley grass also contains flavonoids, superoxide dismutase, and vitamins and grains polyphenols and phytosterols that also provide antioxidant effects. Whisky contains barley, yeast, and water, besides lots of alcohol. Is alcohol good or bad? Infusion of alcohol in healthy volunteers increases muscle sympathetic nerve activity and blood pressure (Graphical Abstract).2 Alcohol stimulates the release of corticotropin-releasing hormone in the brain, which has sympatho-excitatory effects. As such dexamethasone suppresses the pressor response of alcohol. These sympathoexcitatory effects are the reason why, after too heavy a party, we wake up at 3 am with palpitations unable to get back to sleep. It has been implied that this sympatho-excitatory effect may explain why habitual alcohol consumption is does-dependently associated with an increase in blood pressure. However, in prospectively followed 28 848 women from the Women’s Health Study and 13 455 men from the Physicians’ Health Study free of baseline hypertension, CV disease, and cancer, light-to-moderate alcohol consumption decreased hypertension risk in women, but increased it in men. The threshold for hypertension risk emerged at 4 drinks per day or more in women but already at 1 drink per day or more in men.3 Besides its sympathoexcitatory effects, the calory intake associated with habitual alcohol consumption leads to increases in body weight, which may also contribute to the increases in blood pressure. Furthermore, the sympatho-excitatory action may explain the strong association of daily alcohol consumption with atrial fibrillation;4 indeed, the risk of the arrhythmia increases already with one drink a day and continues to increase with any additional drink per day. Does alcohol protect from myocardial infarction and stroke? The INTERHEART study with a case–control design (not randomized as nobody wanted to end up in the placebo group…) showed some protection with moderate alcohol consumption (i.e. up to 4 drinks/week),5 an observation confirmed by a systematic review and meta-analysis 6 However, others have challenged that conclusion. A genetic epidemiology study involving >500 000 subjects found that the apparent protective effect of moderate alcohol intake against stroke is largely non-causal. Alcohol consumption uniformly increased blood pressure and stroke risk in that analysis and appeared to have little effect on myocardial infarction.7 Also, concerning is the fact that alcohol consumption, even at moderate levels, is associated with adverse brain outcomes in a dose-dependent fashion including hippocampal atrophy, differences in corpus callosum microstructure, and faster decline in lexical fluency.8 Finally, high-level alcohol consumption has been linked to dementia due to reduction in brain volume and MRI signs of brain damage (Graphical Abstract). Thus, overall alcohol provides little if any health protection. The late Norman Hollenberg heard that the Kuna Indians living on an island outside of Panama consumed lots of salt and paradoxically had low blood pressure and decided to spend a sabbatical there.9 Indeed, the Kuna Indians ate cacao nuts with salt, yet their blood pressure remained around 110/70 mmHg throughout life. Biochemical analyses of their urine showed that they excrete lots of derivatives of nitric oxide due to the stimulation of nitric oxide synthase by the flavonol epicathechin, an ingredient of cacao beans. Of note, when Kuna Indians move from their island to Panama City this protection is lost. Chocolate is made out of cacao beans with different amounts of milk and sugar. Cacao may loose the protective epicathecin, depending on how they are dried and roasted. As it turned out dark, bitter chocolate that is adstringent in the cheeks is CV protective. Indeed, dark, but not milk chocolate improves endothelial function in otherwise healthy smokers. This endothelial protection has been confirmed in coronary arteries using the cold pressor test to assess vasomotion.10 Furthermore, dark chocolate has positive effects on blood pressure, insulin resistance and platelet function (Graphical Abstract). Finally, large registries suggest an inverse relation of chocolate consumption with major CV events, although the evidence is somewhat limited. 11 Chocolate may even improve brain function. The downside is that in particular milk chocolate contains fat and sugar and thus calories that may increase the body weight. The goat herder Kaldi, so the legend goes, discovered coffee beans in ancient Ethiopia when after eating berries from a certain tree, his goats became so energetic that they did not want to sleep at night. Even today, a coffee in the morning is a must for most of us to get going; and indeed, it stimulates the sympathetic nervous system and causes palpitations and increases blood pressure in those not used to it.12 Unlike virgin drinkers, habitual drinkers are protected from the stimulatory cardiovascular effects of coffee due to down-regulation of the sympathetic response. Surprisingly, this effect of coffee is independent of caffeine und due to another ingredient(s) that remain to be discovered. Furthermore, coffee enhances the cardiovascular response to mental stress in nonhabitual coffee drinkers, with an additional increase in systolic BP, whereas in habitual drinkers, the response is blunted (Graphical Abstract). Caffeine alone does not exert any potentiating effect, confirming that again ingredient(s) other than caffeine are at least partially responsible. In line with this observation, moderate coffee consumption is inversely associated with the risk of heart failure, with the largest effect with 4 servings per day, recently confirmed in a machine learning analysis of several registries.13 Most likely, moderate coffee drinking attenuates the massive sympathetic activation in heart failure and as such provides some protection. In a large registry involving 42 659 participants of the European Prospective Investigation into Cancer and Nutrition (EPIC)–Germany study, coffee consumption during 9 years of follow-up, did not affect the overall risk of chronic disease. However, both caffeinated and decaffeinated coffee consumption (4 vs. <1 cup/day) was associated with a lower risk of Type 2 diabetes.14 A large NIH study found coffee consumption inversely associated with mortality, specifically with 4 or 5 cups/day for heart and respiratory disease, stroke, injuries and accidents, diabetes, and infections, but not cancer.15 Are wine, chocolate, coffee: forbidden joys? Well, wine is truly a joy, but at best neutral when consumed in moderation. Chocolate is a joy for our CV system, if consumed in dark, bitter form. And coffee? It wakes us up, less so, if you drink it regularly, and at that dose of up to 4 cups a day, might even be protective. An abstract of this article was published in the Eur J Prev Cardiol 2021 based on a lecture given at the EuroPrevent 2021 on 15 April 2021. Conflict of interest: Work of the author on chocolate and epicathecin was in part funded by Nestle and MARS, Inc by unrestricted grants to the institution.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Thomas F. Lüscher (2021) conducted a review in Cardiovascular health. Wine, chocolate, and coffee consumption was evaluated. Moderate wine consumption is at best neutral, dark chocolate provides cardiovascular benefits, and regular coffee intake up to 4 cups a day might be protective against cardiovascular diseases.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: