Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Context Regulations restricting the use of pesticide active ingredients are often enacted because new information on environmental and human health hazards is identified. Restrictions on pesticide use can disrupt pest management programs and cause significant economic impacts depending on the price, availability, and effectiveness of alternative products. When developing policies, regulators often face legal requirements to obtain projections of the costs of potential regulations. Objectives Ex-ante analyses are important in guiding policy decisions, but post-hoc evaluation of cost projection methods and results is rarely conducted. Our study aimed to identify how unpredictable changes in pest management practices, product prices, and agricultural systems in response to regulation or external factors may affect the accuracy of projections. Methods We evaluate the accuracy of projections made prior to the 2020 withdrawal of the insecticide chlorpyrifos in California using data from the post-withdrawal period 2020–2022 and identify the relative contributions of changes in crop acreage, pesticide prices, and pesticide use decisions to management costs in six commodities (almond, alfalfa, citrus, cotton, grape, and walnut). Results and conclusions We find changes in statewide acreage contributed most to differences between projected and realized costs; increased almond acreage led to underestimated costs, while decreased alfalfa, cotton, and table grape acreage overestimated costs. Increases in pesticide prices contributed most to underestimated costs in citrus, wine grapes, and walnuts. In most cases, the assumption that alternatives would replace chlorpyrifos proportionate to their use prior to withdrawal was accurate. Significance We conclude that economic projections of costs of pesticide regulations pre-enactment can adequately represent realized costs and identify ways to enrich ex-ante analyses based on available information.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lee et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: