Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
It has recently been shown that kidneys from spouses and unrelated living donors have an unexpectedly high graft survival rate (1). One of the main hindrances to using unrelated living donors is ABO incompatibility. A possible solution, proposed by Rapaport, is to create a living donor pool (2). Ross et al. proposed that pairs of donor-recipient spouses be matched in order to donate to each other's partners(3). However, this elaborate proposal was made without actually computing the potential impact of the “solution.” As shown in Table 1 below, the actual percentage of spouses who could benefit by such an exchange is only 3%! This low percentage is due to the fact that most ABO incompatibilities occur on the left side of the table, which makes it impossible to match two sets of spouses who could potentially exchange kidneys. Only in instances involving a type A or type B donor or recipient, as shown in the right column, would this paired exchange be plausible. Since this exchange would be limited to only the rarest combinations, no more than 3% of spousal pairs could participate. If there is to be an exchange based on ABO incompatibility, it would have to be based on a computerized nationwide pool (4). Even with such a pool, red cell type O donors would be in short supply since type O donors can donate to recipients of all types and would prefer to donate directly to their spouse. Only O donors excluded by a positive HLA crossmatch with the recipients might be available. Therefore, we believe the only practical alternative is to do immunoadsorption of the anti-A and anti-B antibodies(5). Paul I. Terasaki1 David W. Gjertson J.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Terasaki et al. (1998) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: