Why the study?
Do self-reported physical activity levels and kinesiophobia differ between survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and patients with myocardial infarction?
Do self-reported physical activity levels and kinesiophobia differ between survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and patients with myocardial infarction?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
OHCA survivors experience higher levels of kinesiophobia compared to MI patients despite similar self-reported physical activity, highlighting the need for targeted psychological support alongside physical activity monitoring in cardiac rehabilitation.
This invited commentary refers to ‘Comparison of self-reported physical activity between survivors of out-of-hospital cardiac arrest and patients with myocardial infarction without cardiac arrest: a case-control study’ by K. Heimburg et al. https://doi.org/10.1093/eurjcn/zvaf032. It is evident that comprehensive cardiac rehabilitation (CR) programmes for cardiovascular populations are essential to ensure favourable outcomes. As highlighted by Heimburg et al.1 the European Association of Preventive Cardiology in fact encourage MI patients including out-of-hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) survivors of ischaemic aetiology to engage in physical activity to prevent future cardiac events. Core components of these recommendations include exercise training and patient education.2 Historically, CR programmes have been designed to populations with cardiovascular diseases (CVD) like patients who have experienced a myocardial infarction (MI),3 patients diagnosed with heart failure4 or after heart valve replacement.5 Nevertheless, at the hospital level, services for OHCA survivors are provided less consistently than for patients diagnosed with MI, for whom CR is considered standard care.6 This despite the fact that the majority of OHCA survivors are eligible to enrolment in a CR programme. However, OHCA survivors constitute a heterogeneous population and have been shown not to follow the typical CVD referral pathway into generic CR services.6 This divergence may be influenced by factors such as the cause of the OHCA or variations in national or insurance coverage. Contrary to MI patients, physical, neurological, cognitive, emotional, and social consequences of OHCA survival are more commonly expected to linger long-term.7 Given these long-term challenges, it is surprising that the authors found no significant difference in self-reported physical activity levels between OHCA survivors and MI controls seven months after the cardiac event. Although both patient groups may face similar challenges in meeting physical activity recommendations, with activity levels comparable to those of the general population, the following factors must be considered. First, Heimburg et al. previously found that OHCA survivors tend to overestimate their physical activity levels,8 suggesting that the proportion of patients classified as not meeting physical activity recommendations may be underestimated. This discrepancy between objective and self-reported measures may be due to a lack of insight into or a perception of non-impairment stemming from cognitive challenges following cardiac arrest.9 These challenges could, to some extent, explain the difficulty for OHCA survivors to accurately assess their own physical activity level, a factor that may not apply to MI patients. Second, the phenomenon of ‘response shift’ in patient-reported outcomes should be considered. Response shift refers to measurement of subjective health domains that reflect better outcomes over time not because the patient is doing better but because the patient has now adapted to a new norm, psychologically, to match their new life circumstances in order to better cope with them.10 In this context, one could argue that, unlike OHCA survivors, whose complex needs are more often inadequately addressed by current treatment and care pathways, MI patients have better access to structured interventions, including physical activity, as this is part of standard care, which could prevent a new cardiac event. Consequently, MI patients may not experience the same extent of response shift in terms of lowering their expectations of physical activity, compared with OHCA survivors, who may adapt to a new everyday life by adjusting their expectations to cope with their often unrecognized complex health challenges. In contrast, CVD populations also have comprehensive recommendations for risk factor modifications, surveillance, and rehabilitation.11 While OHCA survivors and MI patients reported similar levels of physical activity seven months after their cardiac event, the authors interestingly found that symptoms of kinesiophobia, most commonly called fear of movement12 was associated with a low level of physical activity in both groups, and that OHCA survivors reported a higher level of kinesiophobia compared with the MI controls. Kinesiophobia was observed in approximately one in five survivors after resuscitation, whereas it was present in one in ten patients with MI. This is an interesting finding as limited research exists on kinesiophobia in OHCA survivors. Given this finding, a possible explanation could be the fact that during an exercise-based CR programme, kinesiophobia significantly reduces.13 For comparison, other studies report higher prevalences of kinesiophobia in MI patients than the Heimburg study13,14 and almost 50% of OHCA survivors has been found to report challenges because of physical disabilities 6 months post-cardiac arrest.15 The European Resuscitation Council guidelines recommend functional assessments of physical impairments before discharge and at long-term follow-up to guide targeted rehabilitation strategies.16 Importantly, a recent study found that cardiac arrest-induced anxiety arises from daily reminders of the event such as chest compression pain and manifests through excessive monitoring and avoidance of physical activities that increase heart rate.17 If kinesiophobia is effectively managed, OHCA survivors may be able to significantly improve their physical activity levels and overall recovery outcomes (Figure 1). Since they already engage in activity similar to MI patients despite higher fear of movement, targeted psychological and rehabilitative interventions could help them surpass current limitations and potentially enhance their quality of life further. Pathway of an Out-of-Hospital cardiac arrest survivor to active recovery. Physical activity monitors (PAMs) have been widely used to promote physical activity after hospital discharge in several patient populations. This low-cost intervention has demonstrated moderate effectiveness, leading to an average increase of 1235 daily steps.18 However, for individuals with kinesiophobia, the effectiveness of PAM interventions may be less effective, and might not be a relevant intervention at all. Cardiac arrest-induced anxiety as well as the fear of movement can result in avoidance of physical activity, despite the monitor’s feedback and motivational cues. Therefore, it is crucial to complement the use of PAMs with supportive measures that address underlying psychological barriers. Identifying fear of movement early in the rehabilitation process is essential if a PAM-based intervention is considered. Hence, individually tailored approaches that integrate psychological support alongside physical activity monitoring may better address the complex needs of this population. Such measures may include psychoeducation, graded exposure to physical activity, and close follow-up to ensure that technology does not serve as the sole motivational driver. Kinesiophobia is a significant barrier to physical activity, with OHCA survivors experiencing higher levels of fear of movement compared with MI patients, emphasizing the need for targeted interventions. Technology-based interventions like PAMs should be complemented with psychological support, addressing fear of movement, and promoting confidence in physical activity post-cardiac event. CR programmes should be more inclusive of OHCA survivors, ensuring they receive the same standard of care as MI patients, with tailored support for their complex needs. Mette Kirstine Wagner (Writing—original draft [lead], Writing—review & editing [equal]), Pernille Palm (Writing—review & editing [equal]), and Jan Christensen (Writing—original draft [supporting], Writing—review & editing [equal]) None. No new data were generated or analysed in support of this research.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Wagner et al. (2025) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: