Key result
Combined oral and intravenous antibiotics with mechanical bowel prep reduce surgical site infections.
Why the study?
The surgical community has been unable to reach a common understanding for almost 30 years regarding the use of oral antibiotic prophylaxis with mechanical bowel preparation to reduce surgical site infection in scheduled colorectal operations.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Supports routine oral antibiotic prophylaxis in colorectal surgery; challenges underacknowledgment despite Level 1 evidence.
In an interesting review, Toh and colleagues 1 have provided evidence for the superiority of a combination of oral antibiotics (OA) with mechanical bowel preparation (MBP) on the day before a colorectal operation together with intravenous antibiotics immediately before surgery for the reduction of surgical site infection (SSI). This is the first meta-analysis that I have seen that examines and compares all approaches, including MBP with OA, OA alone, MBP alone, or no preparation, all combined with intravenous antibiotic prophylaxis before incision. They conclude that MBP with OA is most effective, followed by OA alone and MBP alone, with no preparation last. This is a controversy that has been going on for almost 30 years now, and the inability of the surgical community to come to a common understanding on it is puzzling. In the 1970s, at a time when all colorectal operations were preceded with MBP and before widespread adoption of intravenous or oral antimicrobial prophylaxis, 4 randomized, prospective studies 2 of preoperative OA covering both gram-negative and anaerobic bowel flora were performed, demonstrating a 57% to 88% reduction in SSI. The study by Washington et al 2 also demonstrated convincingly that a third arm with gram-negative activity only (neomycin without an agent active against anaerobes) was equivalent to placebo. During the same period, the value of intravenous antimicrobial prophylaxis for intestinal operations became widely accepted, beginning with the landmark trial by Polk and Lopez-Mayor 3 and followed by multiple additional studies. By the 1980s, essentially all surgeons had adopted intravenous prophylaxis for colorectal operations, and for reasons not entirely clear, most American and Canadian surgeons had adopted oral prophylaxis in addition, while most European surgeons did not adopt oral prophylaxis. In the 1990s, 3 studies 4-6 in the British Journal of Surgery demonstrated no benefit of MBP without OA and with intravenous prophylaxis, and multiple subsequent studies have confirmed this. As this information became available and as practice in the United States moved toward admission hours rather than days before operation and MBP had to be performed before admission, some surgeons began dropping MBP and also OA.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
E. Patchen Dellinger (2018) conducted an editorial in Scheduled colorectal operations / surgical site infection prophylaxis. Oral antibiotics combined with mechanical bowel preparation and intravenous antibiotics vs. Oral antibiotics alone, mechanical bowel preparation alone, or no preparation (all with intravenous antibiotics) was evaluated on Surgical site infection (SSI). Preoperative oral antibiotics combined with mechanical bowel preparation and intravenous prophylaxis is superior to other regimens for reducing surgical site infection.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: