Key result
Oral antibiotics decreased total surgical-site infections by approximately 50% and anastomotic leakage by about 40% in patients undergoing colorectal surgery.
Why the study?
Does oral antibiotic bowel preparation reduce surgical-site infections and anastomotic leakage in patients undergoing colorectal surgery?
Does oral antibiotic bowel preparation reduce surgical-site infections and anastomotic leakage in patients undergoing colorectal surgery?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial highlights that oral antibiotics, in addition to intravenous antibiotics, may significantly reduce surgical-site infections and anastomotic leakage in colorectal surgery, though evidence quality remains a limitation.
Despite decades of progress, surgical-site infections (SSIs) remain the Achilles’ heel of colorectal surgery. Although the burden of superficial and deep SSIs has been reduced by care bundles including the expansion of minimally invasive surgery, the rate of the most feared complication, anastomotic leakage, has remained somewhat unchanged. Already once abandoned decades ago, mechanical and oral antibiotic bowel preparation (MOABP) has experienced a resurgence, in part due to a large retrospective series from the American College of Surgeons National Surgical Quality Improvement Program (ACS-NSQIP) registry showing a benefit in reducing SSIs1. However, the results from RCTs have been contradictory, and a large, recent trial did not show a benefit of MOABP in colon surgery2. Perhaps due to limited evidence, the practices differ internationally, and surgeons in Europe are more hesitant to use oral antibiotics. In this issue of BJS Open, Tan et al. report results of a network meta-analysis including 60 RCTs with over 16 000 patients undergoing colorectal surgery with different bowel preparation strategies3. They report an approximately 50 per cent decrease in total SSI rates and about a 40 per cent decrease in anastomotic leakage in patients who were randomized to receive oral antibiotics, regardless of whether they had mechanical bowel preparation. Of note, patients who did not receive preoperative prophylactic intravenous antibiotics had almost two times higher odds of SSI even if they received oral antibiotics. This demonstrates that oral antibiotics should not be considered as a replacement for intravenous but have additive benefit. The authors’ conclusion that intravenous and oral antibiotics should be the standard of care before elective colorectal surgery was shared by another recent meta-analysis on this topic4. However, a recent Cochrane review was more cautious as the evidence was limited by the number of comparisons between different strategies and quality of the studies performed5. The network meta-analysis performed by Tan et al. may help to provide indirect comparisons, but the low quality of the included trials is a limitation and conclusions should be drawn with some caution. Elective colorectal surgery comprises a heterogenous group of operations with different complication profiles. The benefit of oral antibiotics may remain low for low-risk right-sided anastomoses. Left-sided anastomoses are also a heterogenous group of colo-colo, colo-rectal, colo-anal and ileo-anal anastomoses. It is still unclear if oral antibiotics are beneficial in all. Interestingly, in their sensitivity analysis including 1304 patients with left-sided/rectal anastomoses, Tan et al. did not demonstrate a difference in the rates of anastomotic leakage2. Several high-quality RCTs are currently assessing the impact of oral antibiotics in rectal surgery (PREPACOL2, MOBILE2 and REPCA), which should offer further clarification. In future, better understanding of the role of the gut microbiome and interaction with antimicrobials will be crucial. It has been proposed that enrichment of certain bacteria such as Enterococcus faecalis and Pseudomonas aeruginosa in the anastomotic site could alter the risk6. Targeting oral antibiotic therapy only towards pathogenic bacteria might be possible. The debate regarding the use of oral antibiotics in colorectal surgery is far from over. Meanwhile, the network meta-analysis by Tan et al. provides the current best evidence on the role of oral antibiotic bowel preparation in colorectal surgery. The authors declare no conflict of interest.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Koskenvuo et al. (2023) conducted an editorial in colorectal surgery (n=16,000). Oral antibiotics vs. Other bowel preparation strategies was evaluated on Total surgical-site infections (SSI) and anastomotic leakage. Oral antibiotics decreased total surgical-site infections by approximately 50% and anastomotic leakage by about 40% in patients undergoing colorectal surgery.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: