Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The paper by Glacken and Chaney (2004) provides us with a collection of some interesting perceptions, from a convenience sample of nurses on the implementation of research findings in an Irish context. Before considering the paper in more detail, it is important to add further to the context in which the findings must be viewed. It is generally accepted that nurses and midwives are relatively new players in the research and development field, with a history that spans just over 40 years. Based on such a short evolutionary time frame accompanied by limited financial investment in research, the advances that have been made by nurses and midwives are remarkable. In Ireland, there has been invigorated discussion on the importance of nursing and midwifery research. A new strategy for nursing and midwifery research in Ireland has been published and this acknowledges the need to embrace national, institutional and professional commitment in progressing a culture of research-based practice in nursing and midwifery (Department of Health & Children 2003). More recently, there has been positive discrimination towards nursing and midwifery in funding arrangements with a number of special awards being made available through national bodies for research initiatives. This has elevated the importance of nursing/midwifery research and breaks the tradition of not facilitating nursing in health services research funding arrangements. However, it must be noted that, overall, nursing and midwifery research remains under funded. Nursing and midwifery are relatively new academic disciplines and their influence on the wider health research agenda does not match the significance of their clinical influence and the fact that they form the largest group of staff in the health services. It is the case that research grant arrangements have been predominantly geared towards medical research, which is now well established, and doctors have benefited from decades of investment in research and development (Rafferty et al. 2003). Governments in a context of health policy reform are slowly beginning to realize the benefits of research including knowledge generation, cost saving, better decision making, and saving from improved working methods (The Wellcome Trust & NHS Executive 2001). The paper by Glacken and Chaney discusses some of the key facilitators to implementing research; however, like most of the previous research on this subject, the article has a preoccupation with barriers to research at the expense of the more important area of how to overcome barriers to research. Many of the studies on barriers to the implementation of research are reaching similar conclusions and it is now appropriate to move on to the next logical stage of investigation and present good practical proposals to clinicians on how to overcome barriers to research implementation. Consistent with health service policy developments, it is important that future research initiatives in this area incorporate an interdisciplinary approach. Whereas the Glacken and Chaney's findings provide some interesting insights into the mindset of nurses in Ireland at this critical point in the evolution of nursing and midwifery research, its claim to be recognized as the first study in the Republic of Ireland to explore, empirically, barriers to research is overstating its importance in a seminal context. The use of a convenience sample of nurses who commenced a nursing education programme in one college introduces serious limitations and bias in terms of representiveness and generalizability. The respondents were all self-selecting for further education and therefore may have certain preordained and biased attitudes about research. The heterogeneous nature of the sample in terms of Registered Nurse qualification, grade and previous education are other factors to be taken into account. In this study, the factors responsible for heterogeneity are observable and a greater emphasis on robust variance estimation techniques with confidence intervals would have benefited the analysis and results and thus provided a greater understanding of the practical significance of the findings. Unfortunately, the sampling technique taken by the authors is not consistent with such a statistical approach. The study and results could have been strengthened by focusing on the population of nurses, taking a stratified random sample and then reporting on results in an overall Irish nursing context. Obtaining approval from a constituted ethics committee is important in this type of study, particularly as student cohorts undertaking education programmes in colleges are increasingly being used for research purposes. The study reports the top barrier as nurses’ perceived lack of authority to instigate changes in the practice setting and it is interesting to note that this was reported predominantly among the staff nurse grade. Such a finding reflects the hierarchical and traditional nature of nursing and represents the antithesis of a research development culture and requires further investigation. This finding supports the requirement for substantial development work to create an open and transparent environment that fosters innovation from the bottom up rather than the more traditional top down approach. It also significant that many nurses did not feel confident in locating material on the internet, despite the widespread availability of the learning resource in both the health care setting and the individuals own home. According to the results of the study, nurses do have access to essential library facilities and research materials, however little use is made of them and again this suggests human rather than structural barriers to progress. It can only be hoped that the wholesale integration of nursing education into third level/higher education will provide nursing with a strong foundation for nursing practice-related research activities (Cowman 2001). Overall, the paper by Glacken and Chaney provides us with some interesting insights, however the scale of the study places serious limitations on its importance in an overall Irish context. Building on this important beginning, there is a need for much more robust research work, before a definitive statement can be made on barriers to the implementation of nursing research in Ireland.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Seamus Cowman (2006) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: