Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Editor—Given what is now known about the long subclinical growth phase of human breast cancers, the finding of a recent study from Shanghai, that teaching breast self examination did not detectably improve survival, is not surprising.1 None the less, Austoker's related editorial, proclaiming the death of breast self examination, should not go unchallenged.2 Many studies have reported a reduction in primary tumour size dependent on breast self examination, which may in turn enable more conservative surgery.3 The editorial's implication that all such end points are rendered illusory by the Shanghai study is overstated; as if to acknowledge this, Austoker concedes that prompt symptomatic presentation (“breast awareness”) remains important. But is the timely presentation of breast symptoms—of which palpation of a lump is the commonest—so different from what most people understand by breast self examination? False positive and false negative “costs” are attached to breast self examination and to any preventive diagnostic interventions. However, an individual who is informed of both the negative randomised data and of the inverse association of tumour stage with survival might still reasonably opt for the potential costs of a biopsy dependent on breast self examination, rather than for the implied comfort of ignorance or uncertainty. In Asia, where high rates of late presentation persist owing to cultural and economic factors,4 there seems little reason to be cheered by the debunking of breast self examination. As one facet of an expanding spectrum of patient empowering initiatives, breast self examination at least provides an entry strategy towards the gradual improvement of cancer awareness and outcomes. Kline has proposed that the rhetoric of breast self examination should be modified so that healthcare consumers are accurately informed and thus empowered, rather than misled or inadvertently coerced.5 Surely this is the insight that public health in the 21st century should be striving to attain.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Richard J. Epstein (2003) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: