Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Preventing surgical site infection (SSI) is critical for surgical success and patient well-being. Efforts to decrease healthcare costs and the burden of antibiotic resistance relies partly on management of this potentially avoidable complication. Many patient-specific factors contribute to the risk of SSI. In the head and neck, these include the type of surgery (i.e., clean-contaminated, involvement of the upper aerodigestive tract), surgical factors (i.e., duration, operative blood loss), patient comorbidities (i.e., tobacco use, poor nutrition), and previous radiation and/or surgery.1 Perioperative skin preparation is entirely at the discretion of the surgeon and it is the ideal target for reduction of preventable SSI. In response to this need, the World Health Organization developed key research questions and evidence-based guidelines for the prevention of SSI by targeting systematic reviews with SSI and SSI-attributable mortality as primary outcomes.2 A broad range of measures were investigated and vetted by an expert panel to be implemented in the perioperative period. This review further examines these guidelines and current evidence for preoperative antiseptic bathing, methods of hair removal, and type of skin preparation (Table 1). Traditionally employed to increase exposure and prevent wound contamination, depilation is achieved by one of three methods—shaving, clippers, or chemical depilation. The majority of evidence supporting hair removal for SSI reduction is from general surgical cases, with few high-quality studies specifically addressing the head and neck region.2 Shaving causes epidermal injury and is associated with more frequent SSIs compared with clipping or chemical depilation. Another important factor is timing of hair removal. Whether hair is removed by clipping, shaving, or chemical depilation, when performed on the day of surgery the relative risk of SSI is lower than if performed the day before surgery.2 Kattipattanapong et al.3 conducted a randomized controlled trial of adult patients undergoing ear and/or mastoid surgeries via a postauricular approach. In the hair-removal group, the area was shaved with a dry razor, otherwise skin preparation and wound closure was performed the same in both groups. The Centers for Disease Control and Prevention National Nosocomial Infections Surveillance System was used to define the presence of SSI. SSIs developed in 4.5% of the hair-removal group and 2.8% of the non–hair-removal group. There was no statistical difference in the rate of SSIs between the two groups. Limitations of the study included potential bias due to lack of blinding. The best available evidence indicates that routine hair removal should not be undertaken if purely done for SSI prevention. This is especially pertinent in the head and neck region, when removal of hair can have important psychological consequences for the patient. In a literature review of preoperative measures used to prevent SSI in face-lift surgery, Dauwe et al. found that in patients requiring surgical debridement for SSI, the most common organism was Staphylococcus.4 Similarly, in ear and mastoid SSI, Staphylococcus aureus was the most frequently isolated microorganism.3 Potential skin pathogens currently targeted in the head and neck should also include gram-negative flora if there is oral bacterial exposure. Despite several microbiologic studies showing a significant reduction of skin flora with preoperative antiseptic washing, its role in preventing SSI is inconclusive. Systematic reviews and meta-analyses of randomized controlled trials have not found a benefit when washing with chlorhexidine was compared to placebo, bar soap, or no washing.4, 5 In the seven trials included in the most recent Cochrane Review, preoperative bathing was generally accepted as occurring within the previous day to 1 hour before surgery. Although these studies included clean-contaminated cases, none were specific to head and neck operations. Given the increased cost, potential patterns of antiseptic resistance, patient hypersensitivity, and lack of consistent evidence, routine use of preoperative chlorhexidine to prevent SSI is not recommended. The overwhelming consensus of available randomized control trials and systematic reviews conclude that alcohol-based antiseptic solutions are more effective than aqueous solutions, and more specifically, there is a significant reduction of SSI risk with use of alcohol-based chlorhexidine gluconate compared with either aqueous povidone-iodine or povidone-iodine in alcohol-based solutions.2, 4 In considering skin antisepsis, the head and neck surgeon must recall chlorhexidine's known ocular and otologic toxicity. Thus, any chlorhexidine skin preparation must be done with great care to avoid the periocular and auricular region. Alcohol-based skin preparations also have the potential to be the fuel for an operating room fire. This is extremely relevant for the head and neck surgeon, because electrocautery is often used near an oxygen source. Preventing pooling of alcohol-based preparations and maintaining constant vigilance is necessary to avoid this potentially fatal complication. Currently, there is a lack of high-quality studies evaluating the efficacy of alcohol versus aqueous solutions or antiseptic compounds in these solutions in the head and neck region. Overall, a moderate quality of evidence shows a significant benefit in reducing the risk of SSI with alcohol-based chlorhexidine compared to aqueous povidone-iodine. Due to its greater reduction of microbial burden and evidence of increased efficacy preventing SSI risk, chlorhexidine is recommended, except where there is potential for contact with ocular and inner ear surfaces. The ideal methods of skin preparation to reduce SSI in the head and neck consist of no hair removal, or if absolutely necessary, immediate presurgical removal with clippers. Routine preoperative bathing with antiseptic solutions is not recommended. Chlorhexidine has superior ability to reduce bacterial contamination and SSI. Its use is limited in head and neck procedures due to potential ocular and ototoxicity. The level of evidence is moderate.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Corby et al. (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: