Half of the reusable LMA stock at a teaching hospital disappeared in less than 18 months, highlighting high attrition rates that may impact cost-effectiveness compared to disposable alternatives.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
High LMA attrition may erode reusable cost savings; leaves open optimal tracking or disposable strategies in teaching hospitals.
To the Editor: The potential reusability for laryngeal mask airways (LMAs) is substantial. While the manufacturer does not recommend more than 40 uses per unit, reports of 100–200 uses per LMA are not uncommon (1–3). In our institution (as in others), tracking the number of uses of a given airway as it passes through many hands at many sterilizing areas is almost impossible. Therefore, these airways typically are recycled until a defect is noticed that threatens their integrity. Our hospital has spent thousands of dollars on reusable LMAs per year, as these units have disappeared at an alarming rate. Others (1) have reported that 25% of their stock (5/20) were lost in a 2-year period. We would like to report the results of a study to determine how fast our stock of LMAs was being depleted. Tracking the number of times each LMA was used was not feasible, due to the many technicians and sterilizing locations involved. Instead, we followed the rate of attrition of LMAs from the entire stock of our hospital to estimate the cost of their use. At time zero, a complete inventory of LMAs was performed by inspection of all operative sites at our institution. There are over 40 operating rooms as well as 4 anesthesia workrooms in our hospital where LMAs can be found. The size and serial number of each LMA were recorded. LMAs without a legible serial number were excluded from the study. At three consecutive 6-month intervals between July 1999 and January 2001, an exhaustive search of all the operative locations was performed by the same single anesthesiologist in the identical manner. An additional search was performed 6 months later to verify the results of the 18 months check. The LMA sizes and serial numbers then were correlated with the initial inventory. To estimate the number of times each of the LMAs was used, all operating room charts for a random month (November 1999) were reviewed. The frequency that each size of LMA was employed was tallied. The anesthesia and auxiliary operating room personnel were instructed regularly about the importance of saving and resterilizing the LMAs. They were told that after each use, the soiled LMAs were to be placed in a special recycling bin located under each anesthesia machine, and that the contents of these bins were not to be discarded. A total of 142 LMAs were present initially, representing 7 sizes between 1 and 5. The rates of attrition of the various sizes of airways differed considerably. At the 6-, 12-, and 18-month intervals, 71%, 57%, and 47% of the LMAs, respectively, were found. Therefore, it took slightly <18 months for half of the entire stock of LMAs to disappear. All sizes between 1.5 and 4 were reduced to 33–42% of the original number by 18 months. Sizes 1 and 5 probably were the least used of the airways. The number of size 5 airways was reduced to only 65% of the original stock, and none of the size 1 airways was missing at 18 months. Of the airways that were used frequently, the very small ones were as likely to be lost as the larger ones. We found that our stock of LMAs was depleted much more rapidly than we expected. Large institutions that cannot maintain their stocks of reusable LMAs for reasonable periods of time may have to consider changing to disposable airways, such as the disposable LMA or the PAXpress. However, while reusable LMAs may not be more economical than an endotracheal tube or the PAXpress, other considerations may cause them to be the airway of choice. Evan J. Goodman, MD Adam J.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Goodman et al. (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: