Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In France today, marijuana is an illegal drug, the possession and use of which are strictly prohibited. The law aims for zero tolerance, and there has been no legal evolution to allow certain uses, as in some other European countries. In fact, it is impossible to seriously apply this legislation and the result is that France is one of the countries in Europe with the highest prevalence of use. For several reasons this is an unrealistic policy, legally and medically: The police force continues to arrest people, often young persons or from disadvantaged backgrounds (immigrants, socially deprived neighborhoods, vulnerable populations) and often for very small amounts of exchange and possession of marijuana. The judicial and penitentiary systems are overwhelmed and very embarrassed, because they must in principle act but know that their actions are often counterproductive. They recognize that the situation is unsustainable, in a context of widespread use; widespread in society, at almost all ages. The application of the current regulation thus has a high cost; economic, social, institutional. However, there is little official analysis of this, at least not in transparency, because of the sensitivity of the subject. The medical response, prescribed by the legal or traditional clinical system, in a context of relative scarcity of care services, is thus limited to treating the serious cases, mostly in psychiatric addiction services, ignoring ‘Less severe’ cases with problematic usage, except in the few specialized health services for young users Consultations Jeunes Consommateurs (CJC). The everyday life of persons suffering for problematic use is thus difficult and they are left with poor services, for both themselves and their families. Prevention measures against the use of illicit drugs are an area reserved for ‘police forces’ or specialized caregivers. It is, above all, a conception of prevention based solely on the penal prohibition and the health danger: by the double threat, the judicial sanction or the medical consequences. Police and caregivers are usually the only actors allowed to talk to children at school. Public health or prevention professionals are seldom invited to talk about risk and early intervention. No mention of the specific effects of various illicit drugs is legally permitted in theory, nor is the advocacy of harm reduction by ‘reasonable’ use. All illicit drugs are treated the same way. Factual knowledge about the specific effect of marijuana could in theory be considered as a promotion of an illegal drug, according to the laws in force in France. The fact that France has one of highest level among European countries, of recreational consumption of marijuana, illustrates the failure of an exclusively repressive approach. Developments in some countries towards the legalization of recreational use or at least decriminalization (Uruguay, Canada, South Africa, certain states of the USA, Spain, the Netherlands) oblige the opening of debates, but rarely with tranquility. The exchanges are reduced to ideological ‘media explosions’ between proponents of the pros and cons, and the struggles of opinion without scientific bases. A balanced debate, based on facts and scientific knowledge, is difficult to pursue for a large part of the French society, still too locked up in a dualistic view on cannabis. But some surveys show that ‘things move’ in the attitudes of French society, gently. A measure was introduced recently in the law, without any noise: a fine will replace the lawsuit for small amounts of possession of marijuana. And the therapeutic role of cannabis is starting to be recognized, the national drug agency Agence Nationale de Sécurité des Médicaments (ANSM) having officially opened this issue. Without a calm debate, it will be difficult to define good policies and good solutions between strict prohibition, tolerated and ‘reasonable’ use. And the delay in organizing regulation may lead to the same inconsistencies as in the use of legal drugs, especially alcohol, where intense and aggressive marketing is now the rule, targeting in particular young people and women. Because the market is attractive, it is now feared that if marijuana is legalized, it will be intensively marketed without control by business actors, thus resulting in an uncontrolled explosion of consumption, in the absence of informed and anticipated governance. The community of public health professionals has been absent in exchanges and debate on marijuana. Public health experts must take their role so that not only the medical profession and legal experts lead the debate, since these are not necessarily the best ‘experts’ in evaluating public health policies. In addition, it would be dangerous to let an unwanted alliance of tobacco, alcohol, sugary drinks and marijuana producers drive this transformation. The involvement of public health professionals is essential to ensure that we do not move from an inefficient total ban to inappropriate legalization, favouring overuse.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Charpak et al. (2019) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: