This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Criminal sentencing attitudes can reflect psychological dispositions concerning agency, hierarchy, blame, and rehabilitation. This exploratory pilot examined whether established contemplative practice is associated with a less punitive profile and whether legal professionals show differences following a four-week Anapana programme. Ninety adults participated in three cohorts: experienced meditators ( n = 30), meditation-naïve controls ( n = 30), and legal professionals or advanced law trainees assessed before and after the programme ( n = 30). The study assessed 21 outcomes: 15 core outcomes covering anxiety, free-will beliefs, aggression, social dominance, just-world beliefs, pretrial juror attitudes, and vignette-based sentencing judgments, plus six additional exploratory outcomes comprising dehumanization and five moral-foundation subscales. The six exploratory outcomes, initially envisaged for a subsequent study, were incorporated during rolling data collection; Group C completed them before beginning the programme and again at post-assessment. All 21 omnibus group comparisons remained significant after false-discovery-rate and Bonferroni correction. The experienced-meditator versus control differences also remained significant after adjustment for exact age and in a sensitivity analysis restricted to the shared 50–60-year age range. Following the programme, Group C showed statistically significant pre–post differences on all 21 outcomes (| d _ z | = 1.05–3.11). The direction, coherence, and timing of those differences are consistent with a meaningful meditation-related contribution, although the uncontrolled design cannot estimate how much was attributable specifically to Anapana rather than expectancy, repeated testing, demand characteristics, regression to the mean, or other time-related influences. Exploratory indirect-effect analyses did not establish causal mechanisms: only the anxiety-to-aggression model was directionally consistent, while an aggression-to-rehabilitation model showed inconsistent mediation or suppression. No retreat contrast survived multiplicity correction. The findings are therefore best interpreted as hypothesis-generating evidence of a coherent pattern that warrants preregistered, adequately powered randomized trials with concurrently reassessed active controls, behavioural outcomes, and follow-up assessment.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Mishra et al. (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: