Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Much effort has been expended in recent years in assessing the adequacy of diets by measuring food consumption.The principle is to determine the intake of nutrients and to compare this with standards of requirements: an intake lower than the requirement is then taken to indicate an inadequate diet.The limitations in the use of these standards have been discussed elsewhere (Yudkin, 1948).The present paper deals with some of the limitations in the methods of determining dietary intakes, and more particularly with the week-to-week variation in intakes.The practical difficulties involved have led to the adoption of many different methods, which vary greatly in complexity.In many circumstances, it is quite impossible to use the more complex methods, so that the simpler methods are used perforce and accuracy is sacrificed to expediency.The extent of the errors likely to be introduced has recently been the subject of investigation, so that the limitations of the various methods are now becoming known (see, for example, Bransby, Daubney & King, 1948a, b).Whatever method is chosen, it remains necessary to decide for how long the measurement of intake should be made.Because of the laborious nature of even the simpler methods of conducting surveys, this question resolves itself in practice into deciding the minimal time which reasonably reflects the normal pattern of food consumption.It is recognized that the amounts of different foods consumed vary from day to day and that, in most western dietaries, this variation may be quite large (cf.Wait & Roberts, 1932; McKay & Patton, 1935).Most workers agree that, in western countries, it is necessary to measure the intake for a week.More important, they also agree that such a period is sufficient to give a reasonably accurate assessment of the amounts and sorts of foods habitually consumed by individuals (cf.Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations, 1949).But there is relatively little published on this point.Widdowson & McCance (1945) and Widdowson (1947) studied the diets of 'a number of children' for periods of 4 consecutive weeks.From these results and from similar results of Boulton (1945), Widdowson (1947, p. 73) concludes that, at least for calories, a week's study gives a fair assessment of a person's intake.On the other hand, McHenry, Ferguson & Gurland (1945) reported great variation in' weekly intakes measured for the 1st week of each month for a year.Their results led them to decide that 'dietary surveys for a period of one week should not be used to ascertain the extent of deficiencies in persons having. . .a free-will choice of foods'.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John Yudkin (1951) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: