Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Aristotle describes practical wisdom (phronêsis) as an intellectual achievement—the most excellent state our rational soul can be in when it comes to practical matters (EN VI.1 1139a15–17). He also holds that only those with a virtuous character can be practically wise, and describes the character virtues as dispositions to feel and desire as our circumstances warrant—to get angry at the right people, say, to the right degree, at the right time (EN II.9 1109a26–9). Such virtues, he tells us, ‘set the end’ for some action, while practical wisdom works out the ‘means’ to best achieve (the ‘things towards’) this end (EN VI.12 1144a7–9, VI.13 1145a5–6). A number of important questions in Aristotle scholarship concern the relationship between practical wisdom and the affective dispositions reflected in our characters, and how we should understand the respective contributions they make to our acting and living well. In his ambitious and illuminating book, Jagannathan develops an interpretation of practical wisdom that aims to do justice to two strands of thought he takes to be in tension: on the one hand, the thought that practical wisdom makes determinate some non-specific end set by our character—for instance, makes determinate the form our anger takes for us here and now, and, in general, what it is to ‘hit the mean’, or act well or nobly—and on the other, the thought that it must reflect a broader appreciation of our virtuous ends, and the nature and source of their value. Focusing exclusively on the role practical wisdom plays in determining what to do on particular occasions might make it seem to be what Jagannathan calls an ‘intuitive skill’, and obfuscate the systematic understanding of human happiness Jagannathan takes it to require (pp. 7–8). Focusing exclusively on the systematic understanding it requires, however, might make it seem like a form of scientific knowledge Aristotle explicitly tells us practical wisdom could not be (EN VI.5 1140b2).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marc Gasser-Wingate (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: