Key result
This letter discusses the historical role of dentist anesthetists and shares personal anecdotes regarding the administration of dental anesthesia.
Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Historical anecdotes on dentist anesthetists provide context; leaves open rigorous evaluation of modern practices.
The letter (Masson & Payne. Anaesthesia 2000; 55; 1130) was a gracious tribute to the part played by dentist anaesthetists in the development of anaesthesia in Edinburgh. It will have struck a chord with those of us who have lived through the rise and fall of general anaesthesia in the dental surgery during the past 40 years, with a number of innovations having been introduced from that source. One of the spurs for my own interest in the subject was the difficulty of obtaining the services of a medically qualified anaesthetist whose performance did not increase my stress level beyond bearing. It was firmly consolidated by the eye-opening opportunity of working in hospital with the local Consultant whose skill with intravenous pentothal and blind nasal intubation left me gasping enviously. However, it should not be assumed that the administration of anaesthesia ‘under the direction or in the presence of a qualified medical practitioner’ necessarily improved safety, either in 1899 or subsequently. Many readers will remember that for many years it was the custom for the patient's own GP to be invited to administer the dental anaesthetic and I still vividly remember one (very rightly) much-respected holder of the Edinburgh M.D. who would approach my Walton II, set it to give a constant flow of 100% N2O, and as he applied the face mask, turn to me with a charming smile and say, conspiratorially, ‘I always like to start them off on a few breaths of pure oxygen!’ Incidentally, Messrs Masson and Payne cannot have checked the membership list of the History of Anaesthesia Society very carefully: there are many dental surgeons among the membership, some of whom were very early members – as, indeed, was Ian Brett, on whose letter they were commenting. Perhaps the confusion arises from the use of the courtesy title. It seems that we are all Doctors now – except for those who prefer to retain the surgical ‘Mr’ or just cannot be bothered to change!
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
P. Sykes (2001) reported a letter. This letter discusses the historical role of dentist anesthetists and shares personal anecdotes regarding the administration of dental anesthesia.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: