Key result
Editorial highlights unrecognized anaesthetist roles, noting ~50% of work occurs outside operating theatres.
Why the study?
There is widespread misunderstanding among health professionals, patients, and the public about who anaesthetists are, what they do, and how they are trained, despite their broad clinical roles beyond operating theatres.
Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial discussing the role and recognition of anaesthetists
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights need for better recognition of anaesthetists' non-OR roles; leaves open how to address UK public and institutional misconceptions.
Anaesthesia, anesthesia, anaesthesiology, anesthesiology, anaesthetist, anesthetist, anaesthesiologist and anesthesiologist all mean something to those in the specialty around the world. However, our fellow health professionals, patients, the media, governmental and non-governmental bodies, politicians and the public at large often do not understand who anaesthetists are, what we do or how we are trained – whatever the spelling. The Audit Commission [1] believed that there was a ‘generic anaesthetist’, confined to the operating theatres, who could do everything, regardless of training, experience or seniority. In discussion between the Audit Commission and the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland (the Association) together with the Royal College of Anaesthetists (the College) it was very difficult to explain, for example, anaesthetic activity outside the operating theatres such as obstetrics and pain management. We also drew their attention to the many specialist societies as an indication of the widespread interests and activities of anaesthetists. In particular, an additional frustration was the Audit Commission's decision to address intensive care separately [2]. This was despite pointing out that the reason they could not understand the shortfalls in anaesthetic rotas was because of the clinical commitment of anaesthetic departments to Intensive Care Units. As a further illustration of the lack of understanding of the role of the anaesthetist, the Audit Commission report [2] on Critical Care in 1999, helpful as it was, barely mentions that the vast majority of doctors engaged in intensive care medicine (critical care medicine) in the United Kingdom are anaesthetists. Nevertheless, the 1997 report [1] does identify that anaesthetists are engaged in some 60% of acute hospital activities and income generation (this analysis excluded intensive care) and yet only cost 3% of the budgets! In January 2000, MORI conducted a poll, as part of National Anaesthesia Day (25 May 2000), where two questions were asked of separate groups in a split sample of a representative quota of the general public throughout Great Britain. First: I am now going to read out a statement about anaesthetists. I would like you to tell me whether it is true or false. ‘Anaesthetists are medically qualified doctors?’ Second: As you know, anaesthetists are medically qualified doctors. ‘Do you think their specialist training is longer, shorter or the same as (in random order) that of general practitioners, surgeons or physiotherapists?’ Only 55% of the public thought anaesthetists are medically qualified and there was considerable confusion in the second group as to the duration of training. In February 2000, also as part of National Anaesthesia Day, the Association and the College conducted a National Snapshot of Anaesthetic Activity. All anaesthetists in the United Kingdom were asked to keep a diary of their activities over a 24-h period. Analysis of the 34 980 h recorded shows that 43% of the time was spent in routine theatre work, with only an additional 7% for emergency theatre work; the remaining 50% of the time was outside the operating theatres and included intensive care, obstetrics, pain management, ward work, administration, formal teaching, research and CPD/CME. Only 5% of the time was spent in private practice. The full Snapshot data are available on the Association and College web sites. The NHS plan [3] published in July 2000 proposes widespread changes and reform of the National Health Service. Interestingly, anaesthesia, critical care and pain management are not identified for any specific changes. Indeed, no anaesthetist (or paediatrician or psychiatrist for that matter) was specifically involved in drawing up the plan. Even some of those who were involved have distanced themselves from a number of the recommendations. Nevertheless, the plan will impact on anaesthesia as well as on anaesthetists. Specifically, I draw attention to a number of proposals: the introduction of some 17 new or reformed statutory bodies and ‘quangos’; recognition of the importance of protocols for standards of treatment; a clear statement that ‘All those providing care will work to make it even safer, and support a culture where we can learn from and effectively reduce mistakes’; and a commitment to make better use of operating department practitioners and develop the role of non-medical assistants in general. An anaesthetist might well ask what has all this to do with me? The daily struggle to get to the hospital, park the car if one can find a place, in addition to questions such as are the lifts working? – are the patients in the hospital? – do we have the necessary equipment? – do we have the nurses and an ODA? and is there a bed in ICU? – before we can give an anaesthetic, occupy a disproportionate amount of our time. Not surprisingly, we have little time left over to tell others what we do. However, I believe we have a unique opportunity in the current climate to make an impact. Why bother some will ask? Well we could answer some of the frustrations we face each day and do what we all wish in providing good clinical care for patients. If in the process there is recognition of our role so much the better. The Association and the College made a start in 1998 with the joint publication of Good Practice: A Guide for Departments of Anaesthesia and continued with the Joint Committee on Good Practice, which has developed the personal and departmental portfolios (details on the web sites). The Association has for many years published ‘glossies’, which pre-empt many of the proposals in the NHS Plan [3]. However, as the NHS Plan does not specifically mention anaesthesia, the lack of recognition of our activities may mean that resources will not come our way, as they should. Members of the Association should note that the current new working parties of the Association on pre-operative assessment, standards of monitoring and critical care are particularly apposite. ‘The Anaesthesia Team’ Association publication relates well to the proposals in the NHS Plan [3] for the development of non-medical assistants. We cannot in the foreseeable future train sufficient doctors to provide a consultant-led service on a par with other European countries. Nevertheless, if funding were available, we could increase training capacity by 10–15% year on year in the United Kingdom. This would also be contingent on the proposed increase in medical students, who will be needed to fill the training positions in the future. However, non-medical anaesthetists as opposed to assistants are an emotive topic. We should learn from our American colleagues where evidence is emerging that a medically led anaesthesia team has the best outcomes [4]. Since no anaesthetist was involved in the NHS Plan, we need to emphasise that the Association has thought about non-medical assistants for the anaesthetist and would welcome development of the ‘Anaesthesia Team’ document. On the broader issue, the new statutory bodies and quangos in the NHS Plan are a major opportunity. Every visit by these groups to a trust should receive from the anaesthetic department copies of the Good Practice Guide and all the appropriate Association glossies. A firm request should be made to meet with the visitors and they should be asked specifically about resources and safety issues. I would also recommend handing over a copy of the table in the 1997 Audit Commission Report [1] which details the 50 hallmarks of a good anaesthetic Department. Every anaesthetist would concur with the contents of the table, yet very few trusts provide even a fraction of the recommendations. The visitors of the appropriate group should be asked to put in writing why, if it is the case, they have failed to convince the trust to provide the resources to meet the Audit Commission's recommendations. Finally, should we go further and all change our names? Many departments and individual anaesthetists already call themselves, for example, ‘anaesthesia, critical or intensive care, pain management, and/or their special interest’, but this is by no means uniform. Name changes just for the sake of it usually have little impact and may be expensive in practical terms. Nevertheless, if every time we mention anaesthesia we include critical care, pain management and other specialist areas as appropriate then we will have an effect. The NHS Plan promises a significant increase in resources; in return, there is a clear emphasis on change in practice and the implication that the doctors will have to adapt most. Anaesthesia has changed its practice significantly since the NHS began, indeed far more readily than many other specialties, but we have failed to tell our story. Let's make 2000 the year we gain recognition as a major specialty in all our areas of practice providing safe care for patients.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
LEO STRUNIN (2000) reported an editorial. This editorial highlights the lack of public and institutional understanding of anaesthetists' roles in the UK, noting that 50% of their time is spent outside routine operating theatre work.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: