Key result
Editorial highlights ongoing UK debates on anaesthetic rooms, pre-assessment clinics, and departmental accommodation.
Why the study?
The pace and acceptance of changes in peri-operative patient care practices remain uncertain, with ongoing debate about their impact on patient care and clinical standards.
Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Comparison
Current peri-operative practices versus proposed changes in anaesthetic rooms, pre-assessment clinics, and departmental accommodation
Design
Editorial discussion and analysis
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Ongoing debates on anaesthetic rooms and pre-assessment clinics warrant planning caution; leaves open optimal UK departmental standards.
Most of us would consider our specialty to have been in the forefront of almost all major developments in peri-operative patient care. It seems that whatever the challenge thrown down to us (or our forefathers), we have responded rapidly with ingenuity and clarity of thought. But is this the case? Can one really believe that changes over the years have been introduced without objection and have always given consideration to what is best for patient care? Much more likely is that change has occurred at a rate dictated by the balance between the enthusiastic and the Luddite. Both extremes of opinion are important but how often when faced with such a difference of opinion have we taken the position of the archetypal civil servant that 'no decision is better than a bad decision'. So what areas in our current clinical work could fall into this gradual metamorphosis to new methods of practice? A short editorial does not really provide sufficient space to air them all but perhaps I might be allowed to explore a few. Recently, whilst chairing a symposium, I was challenged by a polite gentleman from the Southern Hemisphere who enquired 'How on earth can UK anaesthetists justify the use of anaesthetic rooms in these days of medicolegal accountability?' Providing a totally convincing answer is not easy. Here is an example of how diametrically opposed views over the need for anaesthetic rooms have been voiced over the years, yet despite regular discussion on the matter little seems to have changed. An editorial in Anaesthesia back in 1992 [1] gave a fascinating insight into the history surrounding the development of the anaesthetic room. The situation as judged at that time from a survey reported in the aforementioned editorial clearly showed an overall desire to keep the anaesthetic room despite admission that standards of monitoring were not always comparable to those in the operating theatre (and certainly not to the standard recommended by the Association [2]). In addition to safety aspects, the economic argument put forward at the time for the abolition of anaesthetic rooms (with savings in building and equipment costs) is probably even stronger today. As Drs Meyer-Witting and Wilkinson observed at the time 'Anaesthetists will need more "hard data" to justify their continued insistence on their "quiet havens" in this time of financial constraints. "Just because I like them" may not be a good enough reason in the future.' But a search of Medline since 1992 doesn't show any 'hard data' on the matter. To date, little seems to have happened in this argument but will the current interest in Clinical Governance and Trust accountability have an influence in this? I suspect that matters as regards monitoring may have improved since 1992, but are all anaesthetic rooms equipped to a standard comparable to the operating theatre? The Association in its document on Standards of Monitoring does not differentiate between the anaesthetic room and the operating theatre [2]. So if we are inducing anaesthesia without the full complement of recommended monitors, have we informed our Trust Risk Management Group of the situation? I would guess that for most in this situation, the answer is no. This leaves an interesting dilemma of responsibility should something go wrong. If lack of adequate equipment in the anaesthetic room is a problem in your hospital, either the paucity must be rectified or anaesthesia should be induced in the operating theatre. However, I suspect any suggestion from management that anaesthetic rooms be abolished and all anaesthetics induced in the operating theatre would be met by an instant rebuff, even though many will concede that the role of the anaesthetic room may not be as vital as it was perceived in the past. In defence of the anaesthetic room, the modern trend towards local and regional anaesthesia and analgesia may breathe new life into our 'quiet haven'. I am certain that arguments will continue but we must sooner or later provide the 'hard data' if the anaesthetic room is not to become an extinct species only to be viewed by future generations in museums. This raises the question of what other changes in practice seem to be aimed at improved patient care yet continue to have vehement advocates and opponents? Within the correspondence column of this issue are three letters pertaining to pre-assessment clinics [3–5]. On the surface, the concept of having a clinic at which the anaesthetist can assess patients is desirable. As put forward by Drs Hocking and Shaikh [3], the establishment of such clinics may go far to help change the general public's perception of us. Is this really the case? Moving from the operating theatre to an outpatient clinic may mean that the public will see us in white coats with stethoscopes but will that really change their perception of us? Is it not more likely that they will fail to associate the person they saw in the clinic with the person who gives them their anaesthetic. Thus have we made any progress? Far from improving patient care, Dr Baines [4] would suggest that pre-assessment clinics lead to a greater depersonalisation of the patient–anaesthetist relationship. I think most of us have some concern over the idea of someone else seeing 'our' patient and perhaps deciding on the type of anaesthetic or postoperative analgesia to be used. Even accepting the proposed benefits or disadvantages for the patient of such a pre-assessment clinic, it is so often money that plays a part in any such development. As Dr Davies [5] points out, whenever we look at new ideas, that often originate from overseas, we have to look at them within the context of the differing healthcare systems. Clearly, if such clinics reduce the cost of out-of-hours work as in Australia (where such is charged at a premium), it is much easier to justify the financial costs involved in the establishment of such clinics. Whilst out-of-hours work remains relatively inexpensive in the UK, what incentive is there to invest in such clinics. Most of us would far prefer to see our 'own' patients so that we can discuss, in a meaningful manner, the choice of anaesthetic and analgesic. The problem is that that process currently tends to be in the evening after a long day's operating list or early in the morning with the increasing tendency for 'same day' admission. Would such a system be acceptable to our nonanaesthetic colleagues? Why should it be that a consultant anaesthetist work programme usually contains fixed sessions only related to operating lists with pre- and postoperative work forming part of the 'flexible' component? If our surgical colleagues worked in a similar manner, many would only have three fixed sessions (two operating sessions and one outpatient clinic). If we want to be seen in a different light by the public, we first need to be seen in a different light by nonanaesthetic colleagues and managers. Why should not every 'fixed' operating session have an associated 'fixed' peri-operative commitment. Surely, the attendance of the same anaesthetist to a patient throughout the whole peri-operative period would do much more for our public perception than the development of yet another outpatient clinic. With the ever increasing requirement for teaching, audit, management and continuing professional development, this change in 'fixed' work pattern would free up some 'flexible' time to fulfil these equally important commitments. A glance at the Appendix of the Association document on Consultant Contracts and Workload [6] will show how currently ward work does not form part of our 'fixed' commitments. Surely it is time that this was addressed and changes made. The Association currently has a working party looking at pre-operative assessment and I am sure that the matter of pre-admission assessment clinics will be discussed. Whether we can arrive at a consensus opinion – well that's something else! The first two aspects of this offering have coincidentally touched upon matters relating to current working parties of the Association; it would seem appropriate therefore to end with a third. In 1992, the Association published guidance on departmental secretariat and accommodation [7]. At that time, a recommended schedule of accommodation for a department of 10 WTE consultants was provided. In consultant office space, there was more than 80 square metres allocated. Even if consultant numbers had stayed static over the years, one must wonder how many departments have been able to achieve such a standard of accommodation. But, of course, consultant numbers have been steadily increasing over the past decade. Taking this past document and extrapolating to my own department, we would need a total space of more than 600 square metres – and that is without the academic department. A current working party is once again tackling the problem of accommodation. When one first looks at the accommodation needs of a department of anaesthetics, it is tempting to feel that requirements for space, based on Hospital Building Notes, are so large as to be unrealistic. But with a little more thought one realises that there is no such thing as a simple department. As pointed out by the Audit Commission [8], anaesthesia is involved in more than 60% of a hospital's income generation and so any department will require accommodation for intensive care, pain clinics, teaching and adequate rest areas. We must not forget the trainees; a small cupboard or corridor is certainly not acceptable or conducive to study. What of secretarial support – a ratio of one WTE secretary to 10 consultants does not seem unusual around the country! For most, if not all, departments, accommodation is woefully inadequate. In this aspect of potential changes, there are unlikely to be very many voices raised in opposition to proposals for more appropriate departmental accommodation. One hates to make comparisons, but would other clinical departments tolerate the accommodation provided to anaesthesia in many hospitals? So the times they are a-changing, and whilst I have touched on only a small number of areas where change may be under discussion, one thing is certain, if change is likely we should ensure that we control that change and ensure that we have a united approach in any implementation.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
M. Harmer (2000) reported an editorial. This editorial discusses ongoing debates in UK anaesthetic practice regarding the necessity of anaesthetic rooms, the value of pre-assessment clinics, and the need for adequate departmental accommodation.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: