Key result
Pre-anaesthetic assessment clinics lack formal evidence of effectiveness despite widespread anecdotal support.
Why the study?
There is uncertainty and polarized views regarding the cost-effectiveness, overall benefit, and impact on training of pre-anaesthetic assessment clinics (PAACs) in peri-operative care.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Pre-anaesthetic clinics lack formal evidence; leaves open their effectiveness and supports prospective appraisal before routine use.
It is with interest that I read the correspondence [1–3] relating to my recent letter about pre-anaesthetic assessment clinics or PAACs [4]. It has obviously stimulated a great deal of thought. Of particular interest were the views of Dr J. R. Davies and Dr D. B. Baines, which I feel warrant further discussion. Dr Davies states that while PAACs may be a valuable adjunct to anaesthetic practice in the UK, the cost of such a system may not comply with the cost-effective nature of the NHS. (A sentiment shared by many of us in relation to a variety of treatments and practices within the NHS!) In his argument he compares the pay structure of doctors in Australia and the UK, citing increased payments for ‘out of hours work’ as one reason for the possible use of daytime clinics in place of evening ‘premeds’. This is not entirely true as it makes the assumption that all hospital doctors in the Australian system are paid in such a fashion. Trainees (SHO and Specialist Registrar equivalents) and self-employed Consultants or VMOs (Visiting Medical Officers) are paid higher rates for ‘out of hours’ work; however, Staff Specialists (an approximate equivalent of full/maximum part-time NHS Consultants) and Clinical Fellows receive fixed salaries. The PAAC of which I have experience was staffed by Clinical Fellows and Staff Specialists, a situation similar to that which may arise in the NHS if such clinics became commonplace. In isolation it therefore may not be cost-effective in terms of salaries, although Kerridge et al. [5] have demonstrated the potential for overall cost-effectiveness in the peri-operative process in terms of reduced length of stay, decreased cancellations and reduced non-attendance. Managers may yet see the funding of medical staff for PAACs within the NHS as a worthwhile cost-effective and quality of care exercise! Other points of interest with respect to PAACs were made by Dr Baines ‘giving balance’ to my previous correspondence [4]. He/she states that whilst PAACs are cost-effective, their overall benefit remains unproven, particularly with respect to them ‘enhancing our role’ and ‘improving training’. I certainly accept that my views on Australian PAACs are based entirely on my own experience as a foreign visitor and have not been subject to any controls of a ‘double-blinded randomised nature’; however, I find it regrettable that he/she feels that they have been ‘foisted on us by the minority’. The system I encountered (albeit in a different Regional Centre to that in which Dr Baines works) involved a major input from Consultants who were far from ‘semi retired’ and, in complete contrast to Dr Baines' experience, it allowed me to give more in-depth explanations of premedication, induction techniques and potential postoperative analgesic options/requirements. Indeed, compared with previous experiences, it reduced the ‘sausage factory’ concept of getting patients through the system. As an anaesthetist now re-ensconced in the UK, I therefore feel I can draw upon my experience of the Australian peri-operative system in a positive fashion. Thus, given our polarised experiences of the PAAC, is it perhaps time for further appraisal of the effectiveness and problems of ‘the peri-operative system’ rather than relying solely on anecdote from people such as Dr Baines and myself?
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Joseph F. Cosgrove (2000) conducted a letter in Pre-anaesthetic assessment. Pre-anaesthetic assessment clinics (PAACs) was evaluated. Pre-anaesthetic assessment clinics require further formal appraisal of their effectiveness and problems rather than relying solely on anecdotal experiences.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: