Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The World Health Organization (WHO) defines biosimilars or Similar Biotherapeutic Products (SBPs) as “a biotherapeutic product which is similar in terms of quality, safety and efficacy to an already licensed reference biotherapeutic product (RBP)”.1 As the patents for several of the RBP have recently expired, there has been a surge of interest in developing SBP to broaden access to these drugs through increased global availability and reduced cost. However, manufacturing processes for RBP remain proprietary and, therefore, SBP are manufactured using separately developed and similarly proprietary processes. Thus, despite demonstration of similar efficacy for primary licensing indications, there may be differences in their ultimate clinical efficacy, adverse event profile and immunogenicity. Because of these possible differences, late-effects may also vary. Two ‘branded’ versions (RBP) of recombinant G-CSF are available internationally: Granocyte (lenograstim, Chugai, Tokyo, Japan) and Neupogen (filgrastim, Amgen, Vienna, Austria). Their licensed indications include: reducing the duration of post-chemotherapy (or transplant) neutropenia, congenital neutropenia, cyclical neutropenia, neutropenia associated with HIV, and the mobilization of peripheral blood stem cells (PBSC) for transplantation in patients and healthy donors; but these differ according to national regulations. Both agents are licensed for mobilization of HSC in normal donors in the European Union (EU). Although Neupogen (but not lenograstim) is routinely used for normal donor mobilization in the USA, this is not one of the licensed indications in the product insert and, in view of this, the US Food and Drug Administration (FDA) continues to require close study and oversight of long-term safety. Prior to the availability of G-CSF, donors could only donate bone marrow. Trials investigating the use of RBP G-CSF in related donors began in the early 1990s, followed by study and data collection in unrelated donors (UD) beginning in 1999. Over the last ten years there has been a marked shift from the donation of bone marrow to PBSC, due largely to donor preference. In 2010, 9,248 unrelated donors donated G-CSF mobilized PBSC (WMDA annual report, http://www.worldmarrow.org/). However, in some countries (e.g. the UK) the introduction of G-CSF for UD HSC mobilization was delayed by donor registries due to ethical considerations around the use of a drug in healthy individuals which results in no physical benefit to them. Indeed, some countries have only recently allowed UDs to donate PBSC. The World Marrow Donor Association (WMDA) is an international organization which fosters collaboration to facilitate the exchange of high quality HSC for clinical transplantation and to promote the interests of donors (http://www.world-marrow.org/). The WMDA maintains a database of serious adverse events affecting stem cell donors or the products they donate which all WMDA accredited registries are expected to report to. This global approach is necessary to capture rare adverse events related to G-CSF (e.g. splenic rupture, anaphylaxis) and to recognize trends, as it is likely that very large numbers of donors need to be followed-up for prolonged periods to recognize these low incidence events. Additional information on donor events is available from the European Group for Blood and Marrow Transplantation (EBMT) and several large donor registries such as the German donor registries (ZKRD/DKMS) and National Marrow Donor Program (NMDP) that have published long-term follow-up data on stem cell donor outcomes.2–4 Two publications from the mid-90s5,6 raised concerns about the potential for short course G-CSF to induce chromosomal damage in normal donors which could then predispose to the development of malignancies. The WMDA and several experts in the field produced guidance at that time to indicate that there was insufficient evidence for an increased risk of malignancy in normal donors given G-CSF, and it was not, therefore, recommended to halt the donation of GCSF-mobilized PBSC from UD.7–10 Two registry based laboratory studies are currently being performed to investigate these claims further. Thus far the studies have shown no increase in chromosomal abnormalities in PBSC donors compared to bone marrow donors or non-donor healthy controls (D Confer and E Nacheva, personal communications, 2011). It is unknown whether the results of these costly studies can be extrapolated to biosimilars. Recently, a number of biosimilar G-CSF products have become available in many countries. Based on cost considerations, there may be pressure brought to bear on health care professionals (HCP) to prescribe a biosimilar drug in place of the originator agent (RBP). While it may be considered reasonable to do so in a number of settings, many HCP caring for normal donors have raised concerns about the use of these agents with very short follow up and minimal data in the normal donor setting. In 2008, the EBMT sent a letter to all of its centers stating that SBP should not be used for the mobilization of HSC in normal donors (related or unrelated). This position was supported by the WMDA. The aim of this paper is to review the basis of regulatory approval of the biosimilar G-CSF agents, including the available safety data, with reference to the indication for mobilization of PBSC in normal donors and to make recommendations based on these. It is not the intention of this paper to review the entire field of biosimilars for which other comprehensive reviews are already available.11
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Shaw et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: