Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In order to assess the residual health risk after mere disinfection of drinking ground water, an epidemiological study was conducted in 24 French villages, among 2,033 schoolchildren aged 7–11 years. Thirteen villages which delivered drinking water that did not need to be treated because the water naturally met microbiological standards were used as a reference. Eleven other villages were selected, which were required to disinfect the spring water before distribution because of microbiological contamination. However, after a well-conducted chlorine-only treatment, tap water also complied with microbiological standards. Acute gastrointestinal (Gl) conditions (diarrhoea and/or vomiting) were recorded daily during 8 months using standard questionnaires. The bacteriological quality of the water was assessed bi-monthly. The crude incidence rate of diarrhoea was 1.4 times more frequent among children drinking treated water than among controls (95% confidence interval: 1.30–1.50). This rate ratio was not significantly influenced by the chlorine concentration after treatment. The excess risk was associated with the occurrence of small epidemics. However, when discarding the epidemic events, the background endemic morbidity also differed between the 2 groups. This study shows that after a disinfection-only treatment that produces finished water meeting the current bacteriology quality and treatment efficiency indicators, a low but significant risk of acute Gl infection persists, probably associated with the survival of some chlorine-resistant micro-organisms. Effective drinking water management should primarily aim at protecting the quality of natural water. If this does not suffice, this study suggests that the treatment of contaminated water should encompass multiple barriers, not merely disinfection.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Zmirou et al. (1995) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: