Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial argues that pain relief is a universal human right and that failure to treat pain appropriately is unethical, substandard medicine, and susceptible to legal action.
1 Introduction Humanitarian aspects of pain relief have been the subject of editorials in this journal (Janeti and Liebeskind, 1994; Liebeskind and Melzack, 1987) and the writings of one of the present authors (Cousins, 1999, 2000; Cousins and Bridenbaugh, 1980; Cousins and Phillips, 1986) and others (James, 1993; Somerville, 1994). Yet the gap between deepening knowledge about pain and clinically inadequate treatment is widening—in aggregate, fewer than 50% of patients with acute, chronic or cancer pain receive adequate relief. Nonetheless, a consensus is now emerging that failure to treat pain appropriately is substandard medicine with adverse outcomes, is unethical, and is susceptible to both legal and professional action. This consensus has culminated in the concept of ‘Pain Relief: a Universal Human Right’, which is the theme of a joint International Association for the Study of Pain (IASP) European Federation of IASP Chapters (EFIC) ‘Global Day Against Pain’ to be launched for the first time with the World Health Organisation (WHO) in Geneva, October 11th, 2004. 2 Disease burden of severe pain Acute pain is a major challenge worldwide. Chronic pain poses a massive disease burden affecting an estimated 20% of adults rising to 50% of the older age population (Blyth et al., 2001; Crombie et al., 1999; Harstall and Ospina, 2003; Verhaak et al., 1998). Cancer pain affects 70% of the 10 million cancer patients diagnosed annually—doubling by 2020 (Goudas et al., 2001). In hundreds of millions of patients suffering HIV/AIDS, 60–100% will experience pain during their illness (Breitbart et al., 1996). 3 Adverse outcomes of unrelieved pain Severe unrelieved pain increases morbidity and even mortality in the settings of acute, chronic and cancer pain (Cleeland et al., 1996; Cousins, 1999; Siddall and Cousins, 2004). Chronic pain must be regarded as a diseaseentity because of the constellation of physical, psychological and environmental changes produced by pain per se (Cousins, 1999; EFIC, 2001; Siddall and Cousins, 2004). Social and economic costs fall on individuals, families and communities: absenteeism and reduced effectiveness (‘presenteeism’); costs of health care; loss of income; nonproductivity at home; workers compensation and welfare payments. In the USA total annual costs of chronic pain are estimated at US$100 billion, not to speak of tremendous human suffering there and globally. 4 Reasons for inadequate pain relief 4.1 Attitudes of health care professionals Misconceptions or ignorance among health care professionals regarding pain and its treatment include: concern about opioid tolerance, dependence and addiction; inappropriate anxieties about opioid use and related side effects (Bennett and Carr, 2002); a belief that analgesia makes diagnosis difficult; and a belief that opioid dose should relate to disease severity rather than pain intensity. 4.2 Cultural and societal attitudes Mirroring, if not determining the attitudes of clinicians, are often the erroneous attitudes of society at large (Morris, 1991, 1998; Papper, 1995). These include: the inevitability of pain; under reporting of pain due to stoicism; waiting until pain is severe before using opioids; the wish to be a ‘good’ patient. Such beliefs are cross-cultural. Societal attitudes to pain relief are influenced by prevailing concepts of pain and its significance to the individual and to society (Procacci and Maresca, 1984). In early societies pain was linked to evil spirits or demons in the body. Later, and still today in some cultures, pain was punishment (poena=punishment in Latin). Some societies, or their members belittle or mock patients—for example, with headache or back pain. Powerful myths (and their proponents) persist and spread with the ease of an epidemic—without the need for logic or evidence (Carr, 1996). Such myths include the often dysfunctional attitudes of healthcare workers noted above, and also that: pain is necessary and beneficial; undertreated pain has negligible adverse effects on treatment outcomes or costs. Combating such myths is difficult. Government-endorsed clinical practice guidelines do not necessarily change attitudes and practices—and do not spread with the ease of myths! The efforts of thought leaders have had more impact. These pain champions include: John Bonica, founder of IASP and promoter of many clinical, research and educational initiatives; one US congressman (Senator Orrin Hatch) and a small group of US clinicians and scientists who spearheaded the pain assessment and treatment initiative of the Joint Commission for the Accreditation of Healthcare Organizations (JCAHO), and the Decade of Pain Research and Treatment, proclaimed by US Congress. 4.3 Religious attitudes Religion, philosophy and folklore have ‘saturated pain with meaning’ (Morris, 1998). In many faiths the presence of pain has been incorporated into the very spiritual dimension of the human condition striving to achieve transcendence. The large majority of modern religions, however, place no real impediment to patients’ pain control. 4.4 Political attitudes If all other issues were addressed, formidable political and legal barriers to effective pain control would remain. Complex political and legal issues vary among countries but include: low political priorities for support of palliative care and pain clinics; problems in opioid availability and access; limits on types of pain and/or prescription duration for opioid use—e.g. some countries permit opioid use only for postoperative pain, others forbid their use in children. Another often-ignored issue is pain associated with torture (Williams et al., 2003). In addition to acute pain, torture victims have a high risk of experiencing chronic pain. 5 Strategies for improvement Improvements in pain management require simultaneous initiatives in medicine, law and ethics. All the factors discussed above have significantly impeded an ethical and legal focus on pain and its management. Extraordinary examples include: withholding anesthesia for surgery for 19th century combat soldiers as part of a ‘masculine cult of toughness and callousness’ (Pernick, 1983), and as official military policy of some countries in that era; and withholding of anesthesia for neonatal surgery until the late 1980s (Anand and McGrath, 1993). 6 Pain relief as an ethical issue The responsibility of doctors to provide pain control is articulated in the Hippocratic oath (”I will keep them from harm”) and the Declaration of Geneva. Increasingly, professional bodies craft ethical statements about pain relief, e.g. the American Medical Association “physicians have an obligation to relieve pain and suffering”. The relief of pain is a classic example of the bioethical principle of beneficence (Post et al., 1996). Failing to relieve severe pain may cause harm (see above); the principle of nonmalificence prohibits the infliction of harm. Failure to provide relief when this is available is a form of abandonment. In extreme cases it could be regarded as ‘torture by omission’ (Cousins, 1999). As Somerville (1994) states “many persons would rather be dead, than unloved, abandoned and, too often, left in pain”. Unrelieved pain undermines patients’ ability to think or interact socially. Unrelieved pain contravenes the right of the patient to self-determine his or her healthcare and if severe can destroy autonomy. The bioethical principle of justice can be used to assess the massive humanitarian and financial costs of severe pain and to argue for pain relief as a high social priority. A virtue ethics approach also places pain as a high priority. The current lack of a strong application of these principles to pain relief raises questions about the ethical foundations of current healthcare. 7 Pain relief as a legal right Is the statement that patients have a right to pain relief a hypothetical exercise in moral persuasion or can it become law? 7.1 Negligence law An unreasonable failure to provide adequate pain relief may constitute negligence (Somerville, 1994). Breaches in reasonable pain care may be: an unreasonable failure to take an adequate pain history (Giurelli v Girgis, 1980); an unreasonable failure to adequately treat the pain (Estate of Henry James, 1991) or in the context of uncontrolled pain, an unreasonable failure to secure expert consultation (a general principle of referral is stated in Dillon v LeRoux (1994)). Negligence cases against health professionals and hospitals, based on these principles, have resulted in multimillion dollar (USD) judgements. 7.2 Constitutional guarantees Many of the world's nations have written constitutions that entitle their citizens to adequate healthcare. None expressly articulate a right to pain relief. In the US Supreme Court, in the case of Vacco v Quill (1997) and Washington v Glucksburg (1997) the court expressed sympathy for a constitutional right to adequate palliative care, including pain management (Burt, 1997). In Europe, EFIC has made a proposal to the European Parliament for pain relief to be included in the constitution (EFIC, 2001). 7.3 Statutory regimes Several statutory models exist. There is a statutory right to pain relief in the Australian Capital Territory (‘Medical Treatment Act of 1994’). Doctors who provide pain relief in the terminally ill are immune from prosecution through the ‘Consent to Medical Treatment and Palliative Care Act 1995’ in South Australia. The Medical Boards of several US states also offer protection from disciplinary action when controlled substances are used for treatment of ‘intractable pain’ (Hyman, 1996). Detailed clarification, in the format of frequently asked questions, has recently addressed ‘the unwarranted fear that doctors who treat pain aggressively are singled out for enforcement actions’ (Drug Enforcement Administration, 2004). A wider array of statutory requirements for undergraduate and continuing medical education about pain control appears in a recently enacted California statute (Charatan, 2001) and in a statute introduced to the New York State legislature in 2004. 8 Pain relief and the UN International human rights are articulated in the foundation covenants of the UN. The International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (ICESCR) describes the right of “everyone to the enjoyment of the highest attainable standard of physical and mental health”. Although no explicit right to pain relief is expressed, this does fall comfortably within that definition. Arguably therefore, pain relief is an implied universal human right. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights in Article 5 states in part …“no one shall be subject…to inhuman or degrading treatment”. Although originally aimed at treatment of prisoners, this declaration underscores patients’ right to pain relief and reinforces judicial condemnation of the worst cases of negligent pain treatment. Options for further action include: amendment to the UN Covenants to expressly state a universal right to pain relief (a difficult option, since the foundation documents that make up the International Bill of Rights have never been amended); submissions from IASP and related bodies to the committee overseeing the ICESCR highlighting the central role of pain relief in the attainment of universal health, and by ICESCR exerting pressure on countries to provide basic pain control for their populations. 9 Professional misconduct Patients have a right to complain to a professional or governmental disciplinary body. The definitions of professional misconduct (‘shameful’ or ‘infamous’, etc.) vary among jurisdictions; there may be the lesser finding of ‘unprofessional conduct’. The latter is a more likely finding in cases of poor pain management unless the situation fits the statutory definition of professional misconduct for the jurisdiction. 10 Statements by professional bodies Major national and international bodies have issued guidelines, statements or recommendations on pain management, e.g. in the US, Europe and Australia (Carr, 2001).1 Many express pain relief as a patient right. Although guidelines have no force in law, they are not uncommonly quoted in legal proceedings. At the very least healthcare professionals can no longer claim a lack of credible guidance to achieve pain control. 11 Role of the WHO The WHO, a uniquely influential and effective global public health body, placed cancer pain control on its official agenda in the 1980s. Today, the WHO plays a critical role for worldwide recognition of pain control as a universal right (Breivik, 2002). Its agenda now includes: deregulation of opioid availability (WHO, 2000); assuring access to affordable opioids worldwide; fostering national pain and palliative care programs (e.g. the JCAHO); promoting campaigns such as EFIC's ‘European Week Against Pain’ and in 2004 IASP-EFIC-WHO's joint ‘Global Day Against Pain’; and assisting IASP-EFIC and other bodies to lobby the UN to declare an ‘International Year of Pain Relief’. The last initiative would highlight the importance of pain relief before the international community. 12 Conclusion Despite many hurdles surveyed in this editorial there is clear evidence that humanitarian aspects of pain relief are being addressed in a wide range of approaches across medicine, ethics and law whose rationale is consolidated under the call for ‘Pain Relief: a Universal Human Right.’ Acknowledgements Prof. Margaret Somerville for helpful criticism.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Cousins et al. (2004) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: