Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
We often find ourselves in situations where it is up to us to make decisions on behalf of others.How can we determine whether such decisions are morally justified, especially if those decisions may change who it is these others end up becoming?In this paper, I will evaluate one plausible kind of justification that may tempt us: we may want to justify our decision by appealing to the likelihood that the other person will be glad we made that specific choice down the line.Although it is tempting, I ultimately argue that we should reject this sort of appeal as a plausible justification for the moral permissibility of our vicarious decisions.This is because the decisions that we make on behalf of another may affect the interests and values that that person will hold in the future.As I will show, this complicates the justificatory relationship between present decisions and future attitudes, since the latter can depend on the former.This is not to say that the predicted future attitudes of others can play no significant role in justifying our decisions on others' behalf.Rather, appealing to the future attitudes in our moral justifications may play an important role in our practical thinking but only when we consider the future attitudes of all relevant possible futures.In the course of our lives, we undergo certain experiences that have the power to transform us.Such experiences radically change how we perceive the world and may alter what of the world we most value.Moreover, the way in which we will be changed cannot be fully understood or imagined prior to undergoing the experiences themselves.Recently philosophers have considered how the potential to undergo these sorts of personally transformative experiences should influence our decision-making.Elizabeth Harman (2009), for example, argues that the fact that we (or someone we love) will undergo certain transformative experiences --such as getting cochlear implants, joining
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Dana Howard (2015) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: