Key result
Genetic variation in the KCNMB1 gene encoding the BK channel β1 subunit was associated with altered baroreflex function and heart rate variability.
Why the study?
Does genetic variation in the KCNMB1 gene influence baroreflex sensitivity and heart rate variability in normotensive individuals?
Does genetic variation in the KCNMB1 gene influence baroreflex sensitivity and heart rate variability in normotensive individuals?
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Genetic variants in the BK channel KCNMB1 gene may influence baroreflex sensitivity and heart rate variability, but further studies are required to establish causality and mechanisms.
Large conductance calcium-activated potassium channels (BK channels) are widely distributed in many tissues, including smooth muscle, skeletal muscle and neural tissue. The hypothesis that variants of the BK channel KCNMB1 gene are associated with the variability of heart rate and blood pressure regulation is a novel and an important concept. It is also a timely contribution to our understanding of the molecular genetic mechanisms that control baroreflex activity. We aim to clarify and raise further issues with respect to the findings of Gollasch et al. published in this issue of the journal [1]. In vascular smooth muscle, BK channels are activated by localized calcium release events from ryanodine receptors that are termed calcium sparks. Calcium sparks produce a very high concentration of calcium (10–100 μmol) of restricted distribution (approximately 1% of cell volume) while having almost no effect on global intracellular calcium concentration [2]. This high local calcium concentration opens BK channels and produces a transient outward current that hyperpolarizes the cell. In vascular smooth muscle, BK channel opening is an important mechanism opposing vasoconstriction [2,3]. Moreover cGMP and cAMP increase the frequency of calcium sparks and the resulting BK channel opening contributes to the vasodilation induced by agents such as nitric oxide that increase the intracellular concentration of cyclic nucleotides. BK channels comprise a complex of two subunits, the pore forming α-subunit and the regulatory β-subunit. Different β-subunits show specific tissue expression patterns, with the β1 and β4 units being detected in smooth muscle or neuronal tissue, respectively [4,5]. In independent studies, two groups demonstrated that mice deficient in the β1 subunit of the BK channel show reduced calcium sensitivity of their BK channels in vascular smooth muscle, together with increases in arterial tone and blood pressure [3,6]. Indeed, these studies were the impetus for the study by Gollasch et al., where they report that genetic variation in the gene encoding the β1 subunit of BK channels (KCNMB1) is associated with altered baroreflex function and heart rate variability. This effect was confined to heart rate variability and baroreflex slope in the high frequency range. Work by the authors previously established that baroreflex sensitivity is strongly influenced by genetic factors and the present study goes some way to identifying which genes may influence baroreflex function [7]. An association analysis was employed to examine the hypothesis that variations in the KCNMB1 gene are involved in the variability of baroreflex sensitivity in normotensive individuals. Association tests are often limited by the effects of stratification (or genetic background effects) whereby significant differences may not be due to the gene of interest but instead are a result of that gene being a marker for other genetic differences between individuals. To overcome this complication, the authors relied on maximum likelihood sib-pair analysis. A genetic influence is demonstrated by contrasting variance in baroreflex sensitivity within and among pairs of dizygotic twins, who share, on average, half their genes. Twins have the added advantage of a perfect age matching and reduced environmental variation affecting phenotype [8]. This approach allows a comparison between individuals of the same genetic background, thereby limiting the effects of stratification. The authors used the relatively uncommon approach of structural equation modelling to statistically test for significant effects in their dizygotic twin dataset. Structural equation modelling is a development of path analysis, which attempts to distinguish causation from correlation in complex sets of interacting variables. One of the advantages of such an approach is that it allows detection and quantification of genetic effects in relatively small subject groups. Another problem common to association tests is the increased risk of type I errors when multiple statistical tests are employed. The authors approached this problem in two ways. First, they reduced the number of tests needed by performing a principal component analysis on the multiple, correlated variables that can be used to describe baroreflex sensitivity and used the major factor as the dependent variable in their analyses. Second, they appropriately set stringent criteria for significance for each of the six genetic markers (different regions of the KCNMB1 gene) tested against the dependent variable (P < 0.01, which equates to a Bonferron corrected P < 0.05 for six statistical tests). Significant allelic effects on the baroreflex factor were found for three of the six genetic markers tested. For some of the markers examined, however, there were few or no homozygotic individuals and it was not surprising that there were no significant allelic effects. As discussed by the authors, larger numbers are needed to address the issue with greater precision. Furthermore, in order to draw any conclusions regarding hypertension, additional studies need to be performed on hypertensive subjects. Can the observations in the current study be readily explained by the BK channel mutations that Gollasch et al. have examined? We have no direct evidence that any of the six mutations studied alter expression or function of BK channels. Nevertheless, can the baroreflex abnormality described be plausibly explained by a direct effect of the mutations on some component of the barorecepter reflex arc? These components include baroreceptor afferent nerves, the central neural circuitry serving the baroreceptor reflex, autonomic efferent nerves and the sino atrial node. Indeed, in the nucleus of the solitary tract, microinjection studies indicate that BK channels do play a role in determining the efficacy of the baroceptor reflex, with injection of charybdotoxin increasing the magnitude of baroreflex-mediated reflex bradycardia [9]. In the responses described by Gollasch et al., it seems more likely that vagal parasympathetic efferents are involved because rapid changes in heart rate are mediated by vagal efferents, while sympathetic nerves mediate more gradual changes in heart rate. Furthermore, an effect on baroreceptor afferents seems unlikely because it might be expected that both high and low frequency components of the baroreceptor reflex would be altered in such a case. For the same reason, any involvement of the central circuitry of the baroreceptor reflex should only include those components that were restricted to the vagal component of this reflex [10]. Given the limited neuronal expression of the β1 subunit, none of these sites appear likely to be directly affected by mutations in the β1 subunit of the BK channel. In human brains, the iberiotoxin-resistant β4 subunit of the BK channel is widely distributed, although the demonstration of iberiotoxin-sensitive channels suggests that other β subunits are also present [4]. BK channels in rat dorsal vagal neurones for example, show functional sensitivity to low levels of iberiotoxin, suggesting the presence of subunits other than the β4 [11]. Clearly, more detailed knowledge of the distribution of the β1-subunit in the brain will help clarify the mechanisms underlying the observations made in the study by Gollasch et al. Although BK channels appear to be expressed in the heart [5], at present there are no data available specifically addressing their presence in the sinoatrial node, another site that may contribute to the variability in baroreflex sensitivity. The effects of genetic variation in the BK channel β1 subunit might be explained by an effect on an intermediate, as yet unidentified, phenotype (e.g. hypertension), which secondarily affected the baroreceptor reflex. Alternatively, the association described may be fortuitous because of linkage disequilibrium with another gene that does directly influence baroreceptor function. Regardless of the reason, the association described may well have clinical consequences. Reduced baroreflex gain and loss of heart rate variability have been linked to the development of ventricular dysrhythmias and to mortality after myocardial infarction [12]. The data presented by Gollasch et al. are intriguing, but raise important questions that will need to be resolved before a causal link can be imputed between the gene mutations and the baroreceptor abnormalities observed. These include an assessment of the consequences of the mutations on channel expression or function and the distribution of BK β1 subunit in neural and cardiac tissue. It would also be of great interest to determine if these mutations alter vascular function as the link between cause and effect would be more easily discerned. Further evidence in the mouse model of a link between baroreflex sensitivity and disruptions in the BK β1-subunit [3,6] would greatly strengthen the findings of the current study, although it was noted in the BKβ1−/− mice that heart rate responses to exogenously induced changes in blood pressure were normal, arguing against a central nervous reflex mechanism being involved [6]. As the authors rightly identify, the practicalities of adapting the methods of measuring baroreflex sensitivity in mice is a daunting challenge, but we can only look forward to the findings of such a study. Acknowledgement The authors would like to thank Dr Alan Lymbery (Murdoch University) for his valuable comments regarding the statistical methods.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Phillips et al. (2002) conducted an editorial in Baroreflex sensitivity. KCNMB1 gene variants was evaluated on Baroreflex sensitivity and heart rate variability. Genetic variation in the KCNMB1 gene encoding the BK channel β1 subunit was associated with altered baroreflex function and heart rate variability.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: