Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Introduction: In Physiology practical examination, students often don't realize what is lacking in their answers.This pilot study makes students, the evaluator for their own peers, with guidance of key, helping them realize shortcomings in answers of peers and in the process help to improve their own performance.Material and methods: Consenting first MBBS students at Government T.D. Medical College, Alappuzha, attended the questionnaire based sessions; 3 Pretests each for Haematology and Clinical experiments.Ten questions were answered as pretest by students, key discussed by investigator, alongside students evaluated answer papers of their peers, later evaluated by teacher also.Post tests were conducted and evaluated by teacher alone.Results: The average Pretest scores of students remained significantly higher than teacher, in spite of guidance using provided key with marks distribution (Paired t test, p< 0.001).Different students had attended different sessions so comparisons for improvement from Pre test to Post test were inconclusive.Depending on session attended by student, either initial (end of section) or later (end of study) Post test or average of both was taken as Post test score.This when compared with Pretest score of Teacher/ Student, showed no significant improvement.Conclusion: Peer evaluation scores by student are higher, though under guidance.As same students did not attend all the successive pretest sessions, actual comparisons were inconclusive and the expected improvement was not seen in post test scores.So before and after comparison for each session, is recommended to pursue actual improvements in such educational studies involving peer assisted learning.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Sidharthan et al. (2020) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: