Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This paper uncovers empirical phenomena left unaddressed by current minimalist analyses of French faire-à (FA) constructions in Folli and Harley (2007. Causation, obligation, and argument structure: On the nature of v. Linguistic Inquiry 38(2). 197–238), Belletti (2017. Labeling (Romance) causatives. In Enoch Aboh, Eric Haeberli, Genoveva Puskás & Manuela Schönenberger (eds.), Elements of comparative syntax: Theory and description , 13–46. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter; 2021. Ways of smuggling in syntactic derivations. In Adriana Belletti & Chris Collins (eds.), Smuggling in syntax, 13–37. Oxford: Oxford University Press), and Hu (2023. Defectivity matters: Cliticization in French causatives revisited. Linguistic Inquiry 54(4). 759–796). These issues involve (a) the differing placement of non-pronominal direct and indirect objects vis-à-vis non-pronominal embedded thematic subjects, and (b) the acceptability of embedded negation and, under a more limited condition, auxiliary verbs. These problematic data find a solution in a novel approach to FA which associates verbs like faire ‘to make’, laisser ‘to let’, and voir ‘to see’ with the type of c-selection feature central to Matushansky’s (2006. Head movement in linguistic theory. Linguistic Inquiry 37(1). 69–109) s-merge. Specifically, in V + V contexts, these verbs are argued to have a non-affixal [uv defective ] c-selection feature that triggers the merger of a defective vP complement. This complement is “too small” to allow for the projection of an embedded NegP or TP. The need to value that feature then triggers s-merge, formalized as movement of some portion of the complement clause to the Spec of the matrix verb. The result is the construction’s characteristic V + V word order, with the relative placement of embedded thematic subjects and the attested projections of embedded negation and auxiliary verbs being argued to fall out from the proper configurations associated with Case-licensing and the existence of a second complementation option for the matrix verb that is like Raising-to-Object (RO).
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Lisa A. Reed (2026) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: