Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This essay will provide a new approach to the much-discussed tension between education for personal autonomy and the educational concerns of conservative Christian communities.One can find a wide variety of interpretations of "personal autonomy" in political, ethical, and educational literature.The conception of autonomy I wish to address here is autonomy as one's ability to make inquiries into various conceptions of the good life, and choose to pursue that life which seems to speak most deeply to one's fundamental needs and interests. 1Some have critiqued this account of autonomy on the grounds that one cannot inhabit a "god's eye view" outside of socio-historical contexts and traditions in order to "autonomously" choose a given conception of the good life. 2 However, there have been compelling responses to this objection. 3The autonomous self is not one that is somehow divorced from social attachment and influence, rather it is "a cluster of substantive attachments and projects." 4Such a self is "revocably encumbered." 5 All deliberation is bound by the particulars of language and socio-historical context.However, regardless of this boundedness, one can still rationally reflect and revise commitments in a piecemeal way by critiquing some commitments in the light of others.Rather than being an obstacle to autonomy, these "encumbrances" provide the context and tools with which to pursue knowledge.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
James R. Bigari (2014) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: