Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial highlights the critical need for improved shared decision-making and patient-physician communication, particularly for extreme-risk patients facing emergency surgery.
I read with interest the article by Javanmard-Emamghissi et al. examining the outcomes of patients at extreme risk of mortality undergoing emergency laparotomy, according to the National Emergency Laparotomy Audit (NELA) risk score [1]. I would like to draw attention to the ongoing evolution that is shared decision-making peri-operatively and the crusade to improve the trust in patient–physician relationships. A recent review examining the unsettling trajectory of the Irish medicolegal system demonstrated a 270% increase in the cost and quantity of outstanding claims over the last decade [2]. Regretfully, a strong prompting factor for many patients is the absence of transparency. Therefore, it begs the question, what can we do to dramatically improve the collaborative deliberation process that should exist between patients and physicians to strengthen this relationship again? For extreme-risk patients undergoing emergency laparotomy, this study showed a comparable 30-day mortality rate (58% vs. 63%) between those who underwent surgical intervention and those who did not [1]. Consequently, a plea is there to rapidly understand and successfully adopt a consultation style that merges patient values and preferences with bespoke physician knowledge and expertise. Cobianchi et al. conducted an international survey of trauma and emergency surgeons exploring their understanding and use of shared decision-making [3]. This underscored the ongoing barriers to patient inclusion in formulating a plan regarding their own health and well-being. In this survey, less than half of the surgeons understood shared decision-making and 30% saw value in utilising the multidisciplinary team, specifically excluding the patient [3]. While I'm in agreement that resolution-focused consultations are unavoidable in certain circumstances, there is a role for partnering with patients and appropriately framing information during discussions regarding their future and outcome. While appreciating the difference in approach between lifesaving and life-enhancing surgical intervention, Shaw et al. demonstrated various types of consultations in practice with approaches that included a varying degree of shared decision-making [4]. Generally, deliberative consultations integrated this more successfully. This study included extremely high-risk colorectal surgical patients, where considerations regarding prognosis related to frailty and surgical benefits were evaluated. When the platform evaluating the role for intervention arises, it certainly opens the door for patient-centred discussion about what surgery realistically means, postoperative quality of life and the biological, psychological and social implications for patients and their families. It also caters to a superior and crucial environment where patient expectation is more realistically set. The importance of deliberative consultations highlights the consequence of early reviews in pre-operative surgical and anaesthetic assessment clinics where decisional conflict and anxiety can be targeted early. It is also important to recognise that these discussions should not be limited to high-risk patients and all have an entitlement to be involved in the decision-making process. Whilst significant efforts have been made in recent years with an evolution of UK law to enhance the concept of shared decision-making following a landmark case in 2015 [5], where do we go from here and how can we continue to feasibly improve the approach of practitioners today? In 2021, a trial in the USA demonstrated the improvement of decision-making quality using artificial intelligence compared with more traditional methods [6]. Should shared decision-making be included in clinical guidelines or should a stronger emphasis on non-biological aspects of patient care be explicitly considered from the outset of medical training? Whilst a positive shift in decision-making is evident in recent years, there is still a lot of work to be done and I applaud the author's discussion on the subject.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
C. Murphy (2023) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: