Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
(See the article by knoll et al, on pages 1283–1290.) Kicking the catheter habit can be difficult. Indwelling urethral (or Foley) catheters are readily available, are easy to place, provide tempting fixes for inconveniences (such as wet sheets and obtaining urine samples), and are often forgotten about during the hectic nature of clinical care. The article by Knoll et al [1] in this issue of Clinical Infectious Diseases describes a 5-year hospital-wide “catheter quit program,” which is similar in its successes and challenges to aspects of other habit-changing programs such as treating an addiction to tobacco or chocolate chip cookies. The investigators implemented multiple educational interventions designed to increase awareness of the problem and to stigmatize it in order to motivate change. They limited access to the catheters by specifying appropriate catheter indications and requiring catheter orders, while acknowledging that catheter restriction is challenging given the ubiquitous nature of urinary catheters on hospital wards. The hiatus period in their study underscored the importance of relapse prevention. They then restarted the program with ambitious implementation of various types of reminders about catheters; a reward system to motivate workers and provide peer pressure, patient education, and patient empowerment; and feedback systems to track progress for nurses, physicians, and hospital leadership. Finally, a dedicated “Foley nurse” served as the reinforcer to help sustain practice change. We applaud the efforts of this dedicated research group in developing, testing, and adapting multimodal interventions (a form of phase T1 translational research [2]) over several years to improve catheter use, with a spectrum of implementation steps consistent with engagement, education, execution, and evaluation [3]. Collecting data on urinary catheters is time-consuming and resource-intensive because urinary catheter use has not routinely been systematically or electronically documented to facilitate reliable, hospital-wide tracking [4]. Significant resources were employed to gather data on catheter prevalence, yet additional outcomes such as re-insertions and robust qualitative data [5] regarding unit-specific challenges in implementation would have further informed the program's impact and potential for adoption at other hospitals. Tackling unnecessary urinary catheter use is certainly the most important goal in preventing catheter-associated urinary tract infection (CAUTI). Unfortunately, no silver-bullet solution exists. As we explore more lessons learned from this study and the next steps in CAUTI prevention research, we introduce below a conceptual model—“the lifecycle of the urinary catheter”—that may help frame the discussion and organize the many potential interventions into a series of actionable targets. As illustrated in Figure 1, the lifecycle of the catheter begins with catheter placement, continues when the catheter is kept in place, and ceases when the catheter is removed, but can resume if another catheter is re-inserted. Each stage of this cycle presents an opportunity for intervention. Lifecycle of the urinary catheter. This conceptual model illustrates 4 stages of the urinary catheter lifecycle as targets for intervention to decrease catheter use and subsequent catheter-associated urinary tract infection. Avoiding unnecessary initial catheter placement is vital [6]. Knoll et al [1] invested much effort in guiding clinicians to make more evidence-based decisions regarding catheter placement, by a variety of approaches to disrupt stage 1 of the catheter's lifecycle. Perhaps most importantly, Knoll et al [1] adapted and targeted interventions for nursing units with high volumes of catheter use and providers with high rates of inappropriate Foley catheter use. However, it was not clear whether alternatives to indwelling catheters were promoted as a type of coping skill to address the temptation to place a urinary catheter. Similar to other unhealthy habits, without a replacement to address the craving, a new behavior is unlikely to be adopted in the long term. In addition to educating physicians and nurses about alternatives, we suggest embedding reminders about appropriate alternatives to indwelling catheters within catheter orders recurring guidance to support the decision to note place indwelling catheters. Alternatives to catheters need to be readily available, which may necessitate supply changes (such as for condom-style catheters, bedside urinals, and commodes), staff training (such as in the use of bladder ultrasound to evaluate patients for urinary retention [7]), and investment in personnel to address the extra time and effort required to care for patients with incontinence. Although the issue is beyond the focus of the study of Knoll et al [1], ensuring aseptic placement with sterile equipment is also recommended to minimize infections [8, 9] early in the lifecycle of the urinary catheter, though admittedly this is a practice with a less robust evidence base than we would prefer. Perhaps the most important task to perform after placement of the catheter (lifecycle stage 2) is maintaining awareness of its existence, as catheters are often forgotten [10]. Knoll et al [1] utilized a variety of interventions that were adapted to specific hospital units, including an electronic reminder, the addition of a routine assessment of catheter need to the daily checklist in the intensive care units, and the dedicated Foley catheter nurse who performed daily bedside assessments. As for the third stage of the catheter's lifecycle, 4 steps are generally required to remove a urinary catheter: (1) the physician recognizes that the catheter is present; (2) the physician recognizes that the catheter is unnecessary; (3) the physician writes an order to remove the catheter; and (4) the nurse removes the catheter in response to the physician's order. Thus, by default, several hours—or even days—may pass between when a physician becomes aware that a catheter is present and when the catheter is removed. Wisely, Knoll et al [1] tested a potentially powerful intervention designed to bypass these steps—a catheter order with a default stop date 3 days after placement, which would prompt the Foley catheter team to remind physicians about the catheter. However, as we have learned in our own work, details are very important when designing and implementing catheter reminders and stop orders—details such as how soon the order will expire and whether to empower nurses to remove catheters through a pre-approved protocol for catheter removal. It is also important to provide education and protocols (such as for nurse-directed urinary retention assessment using bladder ultrasound [7] or straight catheters) to avoid unnecessary re-insertions of indwelling catheters (lifecycle stage 4). Ideally, re-insertion rates should be measured. Re-insertion may be appropriate, which would indicate that the removal of the previous catheter was potentially premature, leading to avoidable patient discomfort with re-insertion. Re-insertion may also be unjustified, which would indicate a potential relapse to inappropriate catheter practices. Breaking down the lifecycle of the Foley catheter—and the myriad interventions of this study—into the above actionable targets provides a framework that others can use to organize multimodal efforts to prevent CAUTI. Simplification is necessary since implementation research can be messy, particularly in areas where the evidence base is still under development, such as with CAUTI prevention. Furthermore, implementation science is in its infancy with regard to the best way to tailor interventions that are useful in one setting to other health care environments (even within the same hospital), as well as the best way to prioritize among the many items (often resource intensive) in a tool kit, checklist, or “bladder bundle” [11]. A common theme in recent health care–associated infection research is the use of dedicated team members to reinforce, rally, or role-model changes in behavior. In the study by Knoll et al [1], this role was played in part by a single dedicated Foley catheter nurse who focused on collecting catheter prevalence data, reminding providers to remove catheters, and placing catheter orders. In other quality improvement efforts, the human approach involves “champions” [12]—individuals who are chosen because they are intrinsically motivated and enthusiastic and can foster buy-in and commitment from peers to promote a positive culture change. These roles are often beyond that of a protocol reinforcer and are particularly important when change requires forms of sacrifice such as additional work and inconvenience. Finally, we need implementation research to catch up to the quickly growing external pressures that hospitals face to decrease rates of CAUTI and catheter use, in the form of reduced payment by the Centers for Medicaid and Medicare Services [13] and other insurers when patients develop CAUTI, upcoming public reporting of CAUTI rates and postoperative catheter use, and deeper future pay cuts for all admissions to hospitals in the highest quartile of complication rates. The same challenges in CAUTI prevention interventions (such as inability to easily and accurately audit catheter use and CAUTI events without resource-intensive bedside and/or medical record evaluation) may limit the impact of these external forces, due to incomplete or inaccurate measures of this common nosocomial infection in administrative data sets used for policy implementation [14]. Yet these external pressures have led to higher interest in CAUTI prevention by increasing the stigma of bad catheter habits by hospitals and promoting calls for elimination of health care–associated infection [15], including CAUTI. Knoll et al [1] provide useful—and, in many ways, sobering—information about what awaits us as we prepare for this challenge. We acknowledge additional contributions from Andrew Hickner, MSc in Information, for manuscript editing assistance. S.S.'s sources of financial support had no role in the design, preparation, review, or approval of the manuscript. The content is solely the responsibility of the authors and does not necessarily represent the official views of the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality, the Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Foundation, the National Institutes of Health, the Department of Veterans Affairs, or the University of Michigan Health System. Financial support. This work was supported by the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (award K08-HS1976701 to J. M.); the Blue Cross Blue Shield of Michigan Foundation (grant 1452.11 to J. M.); the National Institutes of Health (2009–2010 Clinical Loan Repayment Program to J. M.); the National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases (award R21-DK078717 to S. S.); and the National Institute of Nursing Research (award R01-NR010700 to S. S.). Potential conflicts of interest. S. S. has served as a faculty consultant for the Institute for Healthcare Improvement (IHI) on the IHI Catheter-Associated Urinary Tract Infection Expedition, and during the past 5 years has received honoraria from VHA and numerous individual hospitals, academic medical centers, professional societies, and other nonprofit organizations. J. M.: no conflicts.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Meddings et al. (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: