This is the authors' abstract. We don't add key points for this paper.
Commentary Preoperative planning is crucial in orthopaedic surgery, and fixation of proximal humeral fractures is no exception. Fixation of these fractures can be challenging, and high rates of reoperation and other complications have been reported, even in the best of hands1,2. As a result, most studies have found fixation to be no better than nonoperative treatment3,4. The mediocre results following fixation of proximal humeral fractures represent a call for us to improve our treatment of these injuries, and enhanced methods of preoperative planning may provide an opportunity to do so. Historically, preoperative planning has been performed using hardcopy radiographs along with materials such as tracing paper, scissors, and colored pens. Recently, however, advances in technology have given rise to more sophisticated methods of preoperative planning. In this issue of The Journal of Bone & Joint Surgery, Chen and colleagues report on their experience using 2 next-generation methods of preoperative planning—3-dimensional (3D) printing and virtual surgery—in the treatment of proximal humeral fractures. In a comparison with conventional methods of preoperative planning, the authors documented several advantages to these novel planning methods including shorter operative times, less intraoperative blood loss, fewer fluoroscopic images, and better clinical outcomes. In comparing the 2 novel techniques with one another, the authors found the virtual surgical method to be faster and easier to perform than the 3D printing technique. The virtual surgical technique was also associated with a shorter length of stay. The study featured 2-year clinical outcomes, and relatively few patients were lost to follow-up. Since all procedures were performed by a single senior surgeon, there may have been few differences in the treatments provided to the 3 groups of patients (aside from the method of preoperative planning). However, since the type of preoperative planning was not randomly allocated, there is the potential for indication bias (e.g., if certain fractures or patients systematically received one type of planning as opposed to another). In prior assessments of next-generation planning methods, it has been difficult to demonstrate important clinical benefits for patients. In a recent randomized clinical trial published in The Journal, for example, Buijze and colleagues reported on a computerized 3D method of preoperative planning for distal radial osteotomy in comparison with a conventional 2-dimensional method5. While the 3D technique appeared beneficial from the surgeon’s perspective, the study was not able to detect any significant differences in patient outcome. In the present study, by contrast, the authors documented clinical outcomes that were significantly better in the 3D printing and virtual surgical groups. While the specific mechanism by which these next-generation planning methods resulted in improved clinical outcomes is uncertain, it may relate to improved fracture reduction or less extensive dissection made possible by a better understanding of the fracture and how best to fix it. Looking toward the future, several questions remain. First, will the benefits of virtual surgical planning observed in this study translate to other surgeons in their fixation of proximal humeral fractures? Experience has taught us that novel technologies often do not work quite as well in the hands of others compared with those of the inventor, at least initially. If the benefits are transferable, can these next-generation planning techniques improve proximal humeral fracture outcomes to the point where surgical treatment would be favored in the treatment of these injuries? As noted above, most studies on the topic have not found surgery to be any better than nonoperative treatment. Second, will this type of preoperative planning prove to be cost-effective? In this study, there were no additional costs associated with the virtual surgical planning as it was performed using a software platform developed by the senior author’s research team. If surgeons elsewhere were to use this software (or a program with similar capabilities), how much would it cost, and would the additional expenditures be worth the observed differences in outcome? Along these same lines, will practicing orthopaedic surgeons consider the benefits of virtual surgical planning to be worth the time expenditure (30 minutes per case in the current study)? Despite the recognized benefits of preoperative planning, many surgeons today do not routinely construct formal preoperative plans because of a perceived imbalance between time expenditure and clinical benefit. Finally, one wonders whether the superiority of virtual surgical over conventional planning methods is limited to proximal humeral fractures, or if it might apply to other types of fracture surgery as well. One can certainly envision the utility of virtual surgical planning in the management of other acute fractures, and posttraumatic reconstructions as well. If so, the days of colored pens and tracing paper in fracture surgery could be numbered.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kanu Okike (2018) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: