Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A surgical intervention is a dramatic event in the life of the patient. Few surgeons are hesitant believers in the efficacy of the operations they perform, nor do they doubt their clinical necessity. Most patients are convinced that the benefits of surgery exceed the risks by a wide margin. Yet in the face of such certainty and conviction, it is remarkable how much medical opinion on the need for surgery can vary from place to place, and how much uncertainty there is concerning what the risks and benefits are and what treatments patients actually want. The work of J. Alison Glover has been a guiding light to many investigators interested in knowing why surgical practice varies so much from one community to another. He was the first to understand the significance of medical opinion in influencing the rate of surgery. He uncovered a more than four-fold variation in the incidence of tonsillectomy among British school districts.1 He took pains to rule out the possibility that the differences in rates (numbers of procedures per 10 000 school children) were explained by factors on the demand side of the utilization equation. Because the child health services were provided free as part of attending school, economic factors and access to care were not a factor. He could find no evidence of an association between surgery rates and ‘any impersonal factor’ predictive of illness such as overcrowding, poverty, bad housing or climate.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John E. Wennberg (2008) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: