Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Armed conflicts are defined as political conflicts in which armed combat involves the armed forces of at least one state or one or more armed factions seeking to gain control of all or part of the state, and in which at least 1,000 people have been killed by the fighting during the course of the conflict. Globally, the number of armed conflicts has been decreasing since 1995, when it peaked at 44 recorded civil wars (1). By 2003, seven of these conflicts had ended, and in 2003 there were 37 active conflicts in the world. More than 80 percent of these conflicts were in Asia and Africa. The latter continent harbored 42 percent of all conflicts in 2003, involving 28 states and their neighboring countries (2). Many governmental and nongovernmental organizations, as well as research scholars, evaluate the human impact of civil conflict for operational and policy purposes (3). These evaluations typically measure not only direct casualties due to violence but often indirect casualties among persons affected by the breakdown of the health and social-service infrastructure and its consequences (4, 5). A World Health Organization report (6) underlined the use of mortality and nutrition as indicators for assessing the severity of a complex emergency; for identifying needs, prioritizing interventions, and monitoring impacts; and for advocacy purposes. While these factors serve as broad indications of the severity and nature of a conflict, an understanding of the process and therefore planning of the response depends on many external variables and constraints that are unique to each emergency situation (6, 7). In this review, we aimed to assess the potential of selected mortality and nutrition indicators for policy and planning of health relief and reconstruction. We examined survey data from four African countries to ascertain the extent to which widely accepted patterns in mortality and vulnerability were supported by field evidence. We also aimed to examine accepted assumptions, such as those regarding combat-related deaths or the vulnerability of children, that might not always be accurate. We had the final objective of promoting evidence-based policy and practice and rationalizing resource allocation for humanitarian aid by analyzing trends and patterns. Mortality rates are indicators that are developed from demographic principles and are commonly used to indicate disease severity, health system performance, or the impact of violent events. However, the various rates and nomenclature are frequently confused. Mortality rates indicate the probability of dying before a certain age. These rates are derived from calculations for a virtual birth cohort that is followed over time and include the true population at risk of dying. Mortality rates, therefore, are expressed per 1,000 livebirths. This calculation method is commonly used for infant mortality rates and was recently introduced for other age groups (8). Death rates, on the other hand, do not use a virtual birth cohort but use a midterm population count as the denominator. This does not represent the true population at risk, because the number changes within the period considered, due to migration, births, and deaths. Death rates are expressed per 1,000 or 10,000 population per day, month, or year (9). Calculation of mortality rates requires more complex methods that are rarely appropriate within a humanitarian field context. Therefore, they are mostly used by academic researchers and United Nations agencies, while the humanitarian community measures the impact of complex emergencies mainly by death rates. Confusion arises when the humanitarian community, including donor organizations, substitutes the term “mortality rates” for the reported death rates. The crude death rate includes all age groups and indicates the general human impact of an event. Under-5 death rates narrow the denominator to children under the age of 5 years and are more stable because they are less dependent on age distributions within a population. The infant mortality rate has often been used as a health status indicator as well, particularly by international aid organizations. It is generally recognized, however, that the infant mortality rate is not a valid indicator of the overall health status of a population but is more useful for indicating maternal and infant health. Many factors influence infant mortality rates, such as race, sex, multiple birth, residence, birth weight, and the age of the mother (8). Nutritional status can be considered a subsidiary aspect of general health status, since the former is a major determinant of the latter. Although a wide collection of nutrition indicators has been developed, few are suitable for assessment of the nutritional consequences of emergency events. Global acute malnutrition and severe acute malnutrition are indicators based on weight-for-height measurements. These measurements are compared with an international reference value drawn from a normal American child population to evaluate the severity of malnutrition, which is indicated as the number of standard deviations from the median value (z score). Z scores less than two standard deviations from the median (−2 z scores) represent “global acute malnutrition,” while z scores less than three standard deviations from the median (−3 z scores) represent “severe acute malnutrition.” If edema is present, there is always severe acute malnutrition. Kwashiorkor can arise among children who shift from breastfeeding to a normal diet during food shortages. It is an indicator of severe malnutrition of which the pathogenesis is not fully understood. It presents with bilateral edema and skin alterations and should be treated in therapeutic feeding centers. Therefore, most reports provide some detail on the presence of edema (10, 11). The above indicators are used to assess the nutritional status of children under 5 years of age and are not exclusive. Many more indicators for malnutrition exist (e.g., acute malnutrition expressed in terms of percentage of the median, chronic malnutrition indicators, body mass index, mid-upper arm circumference), and all have their own uses; this is discussed elsewhere in much more detail (12, 13). In this review, we used data collected retrospectively for 10 years that we obtained from the World Health Organization's Complex Emergency Database (CE-DAT). The CE-DAT project is an initiative of the World Health Organization Center for Research on the Epidemiology of Disasters (CRED), located at the Catholic University of Louvain School of Public Health in Brussels, Belgium. CRED conducts research and provides training and services on public health, disasters, and complex emergencies. The CE-DAT project was initiated in 2003 to compile, validate, and standardize data on mortality and nutrition in populations affected by complex emergencies for use by humanitarian actors, donors, and scientists. The goal of the CE-DAT project is to improve evidence-based policy on conflict prevention and response by providing standardized data on the human impact of conflict. These data are triangulated and validated by the CE-DAT staff in consultation with a technical advisory group of experts. Tools have been developed for analysis of the data and for determining trends and patterns in the main indicators. Currently, three key mortality indicators and three nutrition indicators are included in CE-DAT, as well as indicators on morbidity and vaccination status. Results from surveys carried out among conflict-affected residents, internally displaced persons, and refugees have also been included in CE-DAT, and the data are available in a standardized, user-friendly format on the CRED website (http://www.cred.be). We reviewed the complex emergencies generated by conflicts in Angola, Sudan, the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC), and Ethiopia. We selected these four conflicts for two reasons. First, the nature and evolution of the wars in these countries are quite different, which provides insight into different settings. Second, these conflicts were among the most thoroughly assessed by the humanitarian community and therefore provided the best available data. We reviewed six indicators: three commonly used mortality indicators and three nutrition indicators that are used in complex emergency assessments. Crude death rates are defined as deaths per 10,000 midterm population per day. Under-5 death rates are defined as deaths per 10,000 midterm children under age 5 years per day. Infant mortality rates are defined as deaths per 1,000 livebirths per year. Global acute malnutrition is expressed as the percentage of children under age 5 with −2 z scores. Severe acute malnutrition is expressed as the percentage of children under age 5 with −3 z scores. Edema is the percentage of children under age 5 with bilateral edema. We recalculated the rates reported in surveys in order to standardize formats. If recalculation was impossible, the data were excluded. For the four countries of Angola, Sudan, DRC, and Ethiopia, we identified and analyzed data from 280 surveys. Most of the available surveys were for Sudan, followed by the DRC and Angola (table 1). However, the scope and details of a survey determined the amount of effective information available for analyses. For example, almost 50 percent of mortality surveys did not report nutrition rates and vice versa. In particular, estimations of levels of infant mortality and edema were underrepresented. Table 2 shows the study and sampling methods reported and the refugee status of the study populations. Mortality assessments were mostly completed retrospectively, while cross-sectional methods were uniquely used in nutrition surveys. The main sampling method used was two-stage clustering. The reported methods correspond to generally accepted standards for mortality or nutrition assessment, but further detail would allow wider comparisons and deeper analysis. Numbers of surveys containing data on indicators of mortality and nutrition in the World Health Organization Complex Emergency Database Death rate among children under age 5 years. DRC, Democratic Republic of the Congo. Numbers of surveys containing data on indicators of mortality and nutrition in the World Health Organization Complex Emergency Database Death rate among children under age 5 years. DRC, Democratic Republic of the Congo. Distribution of reviewed surveys of mortality and nutrition from the World Health Organization Complex Emergency Database, according to study methods used IDP, internally displaced persons; N/S, not specified; DRC, Democratic Republic of the Congo. Cross-sectional methods were used only in nutrition assessments, which were performed in 50.6% of the surveys. Distribution of reviewed surveys of mortality and nutrition from the World Health Organization Complex Emergency Database, according to study methods used IDP, internally displaced persons; N/S, not specified; DRC, Democratic Republic of the Congo. Cross-sectional methods were used only in nutrition assessments, which were performed in 50.6% of the surveys. Angola has been at war since 1956, starting with the war of independence against Portugal. That conflict was followed by protracted civil strife, as indicated in Web figure 1 (posted on the Epidemiologic Reviews website (http://epirev.oupjournals.org/)). Several peace agreements were eventually signed, and United Nations peacekeepers have been maintaining calm since 1998. Today, the country is facing the consequences of prolonged war in terms of a dysfunctional infrastructure, the presence of land mines, and food shortages. The complex emergency in Angola occurred mainly in the western-central part of the country. The provinces most affected and surveyed were Cuanza Sul, Bié, Huambo, Benguela, Huila, and Cuando-Cubango. Figure 1 shows the high mortality levels in 2000 found in surveys carried out among internally displaced persons in camps in Ganda municipality, Benguela. Crude death rates were estimated at 3.1/10,000 per day, while under-5 death rates were 4.1/10,000 per day. The crude mortality rate is three times higher than the threshold of 1/10,000 per day generally used to define a crisis state, and the latter is twice the critical level of 2/10,000 per day. Monthly average crude death rate (CDR), under-5 death rate (U5DR) (death rate among children under age 5 years), and prevalence (percentage) of global acute malnutrition (GAM) for the conflict-affected region in Angola, 2000–2004. Dashed line, national United Nations average. These very high rates reflect the increases in intensified fighting entailing foreign military involvement and their effects on the civil population, especially children. Note that these rates were prevalent among internally displaced persons, a group that is highly vulnerable and often neglected by the international humanitarian community because of its complex legal status. On the other hand, from and provinces rates that were the national reported by the United Nations in mortality among displaced persons in the national with crude death rates and under-5 death rates estimated at per day and per day, This was under governmental while the very persons into and that were to aid organizations. In rates in Bié, Benguela, and Cuando-Cubango. Under-5 deaths but not the national average level of per day. However, rates of were the national average during this indicating that malnutrition not be with because other health such as vaccination and to health also a The death rates were reported in among internally displaced persons and in Huila, as by the in Web figure However, there were very these two with a crude death rate of per day for as compared with internally displaced persons, rates were almost that figure per The under-5 death rate was also much higher among internally displaced per day as compared with per day for mortality rates for internally displaced persons were mainly by that the camps and affected the child population. among internally displaced persons reported severe food as well, with more than percent of children the high level of percent in the conflict, in 2003, surveys from Ganda in reported high mortality death rate under-5 death rate while the situation in other provinces as in Web figure The effects of were by the and impact of land and the infrastructure that have since the of the conflict. has civil since as in the in Web figure This conflict the and the has and an estimated two deaths among and and has generated one of the populations of internally displaced persons an in the region of as of people had and had been displaced The states most affected by conflicts are and and in and the three states and of the region in Figure 2 a in mortality that in in and a crude death rate of more than per day in By state in this was to be facing a severe food because of violence and were particularly vulnerable in this mortality was high in during because of of and malnutrition, with a of per day in while the crude death rate to almost the national average of per day by the of the year before a high value per in Monthly average crude death rate (CDR), under-5 death rate (U5DR) (death rate among children under age 5 years), and prevalence (percentage) of global acute malnutrition (GAM) for the conflict-affected region in Sudan, 2000–2004. Dashed line, national United Nations average. The under-5 and crude death rates high per day as compared with a crisis threshold of 2/10,000 per in in mortality during the since children within a period of high under-5 and crude death rates were reported in in with of per day and per day, an from the national average of per day. of internally displaced persons had to the in a in In was very because of and which the of percent of the population Most surveys reported rates of global acute malnutrition from to that the national average of to almost percent in and while the latter had death rates the national average. for in 2003 were but almost Mortality in and in while the crude death rate high in the former this rates the national average were but they in and in by the of internally displaced persons and food indicators from a situation in 2003, the and the in as in the in Web figure had been in 2000 and when percent and percent of children under age were reported to be mortality and more in when by high crude and under-5 death rates were in camps for internally displaced persons in in per day and per day, the vulnerability of internally displaced persons in this For the and in death rates the national average of were This was as a situation by the of the report The in figure the high death rates in and but a high under-5 death rate is also in the as well as severe malnutrition. The rates of in the percent and percent in and mainly the for internally displaced persons, since people have with health and of and the average crude death the under-5 death rate rate among children under age 5 years), and the prevalence (percentage) of global acute malnutrition, by in the region of Sudan, Although is generally the most affected in the malnutrition there at This is by the rate of in most children had by the time this was by the nutrition surveys. A complex emergency for the DRC is provided in Web figure The conflicts in the DRC from and the of a population in that violence in the in The period was for its when a civil war by and DRC eventually would the of people and the of Although a peace process is under fighting in in the of of of persons while humanitarian were to from the The provinces most affected by the conflict in the DRC were and and In death rates the national average in in and among internally displaced persons in The under-5 death rate to per day in and surveys from reported the for as by the in Web figure Crude death rates per day were found during this Most deaths in this period were by and to a direct rates of malnutrition were mainly in and were in all conflict-affected The high national average of percent reported by indicates a food by the in figure the average crude death rate in the under-5 death rate (death rate among children under age 5 in and the prevalence (percentage) of global acute malnutrition in by in the Democratic Republic of the Congo. In mortality and malnutrition in because of the and the was for the and deaths from direct violence were the figure crude death rates in when fighting in before it was into a from 2003 reported high mortality in with a crude death rate of per day and a under-5 death rate of per day in However, rates of did not the national average in and internally displaced persons in percent of the children were as compared with percent in which indicates an the fighting in this and of persons the conflict-affected is a country by conflict and as by the in Web figure in The a war for independence in the year. A war the independence of in and the of the occurred in The three main complex emergency that exist are in the and and are by and figure 5 the rates of mortality and malnutrition in occurred in in represent the consequences of the violence that in Mortality the national with crude and under-5 death rates of per day and per day, while nutrition surveys rates of more than percent in the under-5 population. These surveys were completed when the situation to international more than years of and to on the of in This was followed by but most of the deaths had occurred by child mortality at the of the year is by and in to the the and high crude and under-5 death rates per day and per day, by the of Monthly average crude death rate (CDR), under-5 death rate (U5DR) (death rate among children under age 5 years), and prevalence (percentage) of global acute malnutrition (GAM) for the conflict-affected region in Ethiopia, 2000–2004. Dashed line, national United Nations average. and In high under-5 death rates per and global acute malnutrition were reported in which is also by the in Web figure These high from the in which was the most affected by the and which internally displaced Under-5 death rates in which the national average in above per day in in the of internally displaced persons are almost dependent on food mortality and nutrition patterns in conflicts are not out by field evidence. such as of internally displaced persons, or certain age do not in some For the of internally displaced persons is generally to be than that of the in a conflict-affected This was to be the in Huila, Angola, in when mortality in all age groups among internally displaced persons was twice as high as that among in the The have occurred the internally displaced persons had been under the of a United Nations or humanitarian have also discussed the vulnerability of internally displaced persons The vulnerability of children, a in most complex is not always from the of the survey indicators. In the under-5 death rate the main of the crude death However, the under-5 death rate is reported to be in with the crude death which indicates a highly violent situation are For example, in the of Sudan, the crude death rate per day in 2003 as compared with a in the under-5 death rate from per day to per day. The in this region to very high which is generally not in other children are the most have patterns of mortality On the other hand, an in the under-5 death rate as compared with the crude death rate indicates such as of or severe food shortages. For example, in the of Ethiopia, the crude death rate from per day to less than per day, the under-5 death rate from per day to per day. The above the potential of general vulnerability in might its while and response would be as of the mortality and malnutrition rates also In some high levels of mortality with levels of malnutrition, such as in the DRC in This situation be due to the of to measure malnutrition in these the children are and therefore not included in the nutrition However, other than malnutrition, such as or can to high rates of In with such rates, of on should further research in order to relief to the of death in complex emergencies do not patterns and to be highly dependent on In emergencies that and mortality and morbidity a different than in of For example, in the DRC high under-5 death rates but crude mortality in with the This high mortality be to the violent conflict. however, that the major were such as and a health The of measures such as and vaccination has been widely however, there is much for as as is is to because of a of and data. a it is to patterns of mortality and This health response and prevention In many conflict-affected data on indicators are not reported for years. of the surveys reviewed reported infant mortality rates, with the of those from the In the of this the of and health is on edema in malnutrition surveys the assessment of in of feeding data from complex emergencies are often of and are often considered for academic This that analysis of key indicators has potential for use in and policy mortality and morbidity due to civil conflict requires a In the of standard data on indicators, humanitarian aid be effective In this review, we the of human to complex emergencies than on objective evidence. should be to the of complex emergency that can the on the The data generated by such a system can be used for resource allocation by humanitarian and can in assessing and global humanitarian aid has to an percent of indicates that the levels of and death in these four African countries by aid be more rates of and death are to be to The that is the extent and severity of the human impact of complex emergencies on populations. The their to the of and of the of for its of the Complex Emergency
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Guha‐Sapir et al. (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: