Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Too often the phrase ‘evidence based’ is no more than a dishonest rhetorical device to suggest that the speaker is better informed than he or she really is. This book ‘Alcohol: no ordinary commodity’ is a refreshing reminder that ‘evidence based’ can be a meaningful phrase. It is a model of how for any intervention one should consider all the available evidence in the literature and then arrive at a judgement as to what that evidence means. The book should be required reading for everyone contemplating measures to reduce alcohol-related harm. The final chapter contains a table listing 41 interventions that have been suggested to reduce alcohol-related harm. The preceding chapters consider each of these interventions, listing the studies and reports (which in most cases are conflicting) assessing the efficacy of that intervention before arriving at judgements as to whether the measure may or may not be effective. Each study is listed in the extensive list of references at the end of the book. A possible weakness in an approach which attempts to draw conclusions from so many countries (a lot of the evidence comes for the USA and Australia) is the danger of underplaying the importance of context. What works in one town, country or drinking culture may not work in another. Even more important the details of implementation of an intervention (enthusiasm of staff, thoroughness of application and so on) may be more important than the broad theory and design of the intervention. The book recognizes these issues but when the main argument is that we ought to be repeating things which have worked elsewhere, perhaps the importance of context and detail deserve even more emphasis. The most effective interventions are those which either regulate availability of alcohol or increase tax on alcohol. At a time when the financial cost of intervention will be uppermost in everyone's mind taxing alcohol, which rather than costing generates revenue, should be very attractive but considerations of political acceptability and government's terror of being accused of running a ‘nanny state’ outweigh cost-effectiveness arguments. Measures against drink-driving and brief interventions also score well on effectiveness. The chapter on education and persuasion focuses chiefly on school interventions and concludes that there is very little evidence that these have ever worked. With relentless logic it then asks why do we persist in attempting to make interventions in a setting where results so far have been disappointing? Rather than try more and more adjustments to these failed approaches should we not forget interventions aimed at school children and switch to those that have proven more effective? This is a step too far for me. While accepting that we have not yet found interventions that work school children are too important for us to give up. This second edition uses the same chapter titles and virtually the same group of authors as the first edition. However, the whole text has been thoroughly rewritten and it is no minor update with trivial changes. Inevitably a book which packs so much content into so few pages is sometimes heavy reading and I often found that I had to read a sentence two or three times in order to grasp its meaning. In particular the chapter which attempts to describe drinking patterns and their changes for all the world in 20 pages is overambitious and the topic deserves a much lengthier description. The chapter on structure of the alcohol industry was informative and contains information which is not found in most other public health texts. Overall this book is a mine of information and it would be hard to find a better starting place for someone trying to get a grip on the confusing field of how to reduce alcohol-related harm. Let us hope that the authors of our next alcohol strategy have studied this book carefully.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
John Kemm (2011) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: