This report outlines the organization of heart failure care in the Czech Republic, highlighting improvements in cardiovascular mortality and life expectancy alongside increasing availability of invasive procedures.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mortality declines were associated with HF care advances in the Czech Republic; leaves open the role of invasive procedures in sustaining trends today.
The Czech Republic has 10 million inhabitants and has 9 cardiac centres with cardiac surgery. Approximately 140 cardiologists work in an out-of-hospital service and approximately 200 cardiologists work at hospital level. Healthcare in the Czech Republic (CR) is organised as follows: Each citizen must be insured in one of the 10 different insurance companies. These are paid from the taxation system of the state. For the unemployed, retired, children and mothers staying at home with their babies, the insurance is paid by the state. The citizens can choose their own insurance company. Primary care is private in approximately 85%. However, patients themselves do not pay directly to the general practitioner (GP) but the GPs have special contracts with the insurance companies. All CR citizens should be registered with at least one of the GPs. Hospitals are mostly (90%) state owned but are also financed primarily by insurance companies. However, the state helps in individual cases to cover the negative financial balance. The CR residents are free to choose their doctors (including specialists). Out-patient services are available at GPs, physicians (internists), geriatricians and cardiologists. The cardiologists also have out-patient wards in the hospitals, especially specialised ones. Most patients who develop mild symptoms of heart failure see their GPs. They may visit some specialists (internists or cardiologists or geriatricians) less frequently. Clinical diagnosis is frequently inaccurate at the GP office because it is based mainly on symptoms and signs, although in some patients also on ECG, and even less frequently on chest X-ray. All GPs can order simple blood investigations (renal, liver, full blood count, ECG (if an electrocardiograph is not owned by themselves, which is frequently the case) and chest X-ray. In the presence of a normal ECG and chest X-ray, the diagnosis seems for the GP less likely. However, it should be stressed that not all patients with dyspnoea are investigated by chest X-ray. The GPs can also ask the cardiologist (either at the local district hospital or a private cardiologist) for the confirmation of their diagnosis and performance of the echocardiogram. Postgraduate activity is concentrating on improving the diagnosis and treatment of heart failure and a special booklet on ‘Heart failure — its diagnosis and treatment’ has been written by the author and is widely distributed. 1. Special guidelines on the diagnosis and treatment of heart failure have also been published by the Czech Society of Cardiology 2. A special article about the difficulties of diagnosis of heart failure and less than optimal treatment of heart failure based on US and British data has also been published 3. Referral times for echocardiography vary within the country. Waiting lists for consultations run from 1 to 2 weeks. Patients with acute heart failure or those with severe heart failure as well as those markedly deteriorating are usually sent to the nearest hospital. The GPs can directly send the patients to their local district hospitals. The patients themselves can, in an emergency, also call directly the Emergency Ambulance Service and ask for transport to the hospital. Clinical evaluation in the hospital includes ECG, chest X-ray, biochemistry and haematology. Echocardiography is usually also performed during the hospital stay. All hospitals have cardiologists who are able to perform echocardiography. Echocardiography is not available 24 h/day, 7 days/week in all hospitals (especially the smaller ones). When therapy has stabilised the patient, he is discharged back to his GP but in more severe cases to a private cardiologist. Cardiologists working at an out-patient ward in the hospital take care of some patients. Those patients in whom invasive therapy or cardiac surgery could be indicated are referred (or transferred in those most severe cases) to the cardiac centres. Patients in whom cardiac transplantation could be indicated are referred to two cardiac centres which perform heart transplantation in the Czech Republic — Departments of Cardiology and Cardiovascular Surgery, IKEM, Prague 4 and the Centre for Cardiac and Transplantation Surgery in Brno. Approximately 60–80 heart transplantations are performed yearly. PTCA as therapy for all patients with acute myocardial infarction is performed in seven centres 24 h, 7 days/week. It is also of interest that cardiovascular as well as total mortality is decreasing in the Czech Republic in a similar way as in Poland (Table 1). The data show that in 1997 total mortality in the Czech Republic was 22% lower, coronary mortality 28% lower and cerebrovascular mortality 45% lower in the age group 0–90 years when compared to 1982. The Czech Republic and Poland differ from some other Eastern countries in which cardiovascular mortality is still increasing. The mean life expectancy rose in men from 67.2 to 70.4 in this period and in women from 74.3 to 77.6 years (Table 2). Prolongation of life expectancy may in the future increase the number of patients with heart failure. All hospital costs including cardiac surgery, PTCA or transplantations are free of charge. After 1989 the number of cardiac operations, PTCA and even heart transplantations increased markedly in the Czech Republic, e.g. in the Cardiac Centre in IKEM only 200–300 cardiac operations with cardiopulmonary by-pass were performed in 1988 or 1989. This number increased to 1200 only in this centre. In 1989 only four cardiac centres existed. Now 11 cardiac centres with invasive cardiology exist. The increase in invasive procedures and cardiac surgical procedures was such that the waiting lists have decreased markedly. At present they are for stable angina pectoris between 4 and 12 weeks (before 1989 they were 1 year and more). Waiting times for heart catheterisation of valve disease or, e.g. dilated cardiomyopathy are similar. Heart transplantation is offered to patients younger than 65 years. A waiting list exists for heart transplantation. The increase in invasive procedures, cardiac operations and transplantations does not, however, correlate with the economic situation of the Czech Republic which is improving much more slowly. Thus financial limitation was created and the number of procedures cannot further markedly rise because the hospitals are limited by a fixed budget which has been increasing very slowly in the last 3 years. Also a primary care budget has been established. A discussion is going on at present how to increase the financial resources for the health care system. At present patients pay only a minor part of the cost of drugs, some of which are not life or morbidity saving.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
J Widimský (1999) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: