Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
In his article "Educational Ethics: Are We on the Right Track?" Jerry Coombs raises critical questions about two standard approaches to teaching professional ethics to educators, then proposes alternative ways in which such courses can help teachers and administrators enhance their capacity for sound practical judgment, that is, make the right decisions when faced with challenging moral situations in their practice. 1In this essay, I raise critical questions about a third way of designing professional ethics courses that has recently become popular, the "multiple ethical languages" approach, then introduce a theory and practice of improving practical judgment that I believe warrants exploration.The essay has three sections.In section one, I recap key points from the Coombs article to establish criteria for assessing professional ethics programs, then review how teaching ethical languages has been understood to improve practical judgment.In section two, I examine a text exemplifying the multiple ethical languages approach to show how coaching teachers and administrators in a range of ethical languages is not sufficient to help them improve their decision-making in the complex moral contexts of professional practice.In the third and final section, I propose, taking Robert Nash's reference to "moral discernment" 2 as my cue, that instructors of professional ethics courses should pay greater attention to the intuitive dimension of the theory-practice dialectic through which educational professionals -ourselves not least -might cultivate the conditions for sound practical judgment.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Daniel Vokey (2005) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: