Key result
Millions of children in the United States live more than 50 miles from a pediatric anesthesiologist, highlighting the need for regionalized care, teleconsultation, and mobile surgical teams.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This editorial highlights geographic disparities in access to pediatric anesthesiologists in the US and advocates for novel outreach strategies such as teleanesthesia and mobile surgical teams.
Ensuring safe, effective, and high-quality care for children of all ages is paramount to pediatric anesthesiologists and to leaders and members of the Society for Pediatric Anesthesia. To this end, recent studies provide important data that inform the planning and implementation of ideal children’s perioperative services. For instance, data have demonstrated that children anesthetized in pediatric settings by pediatric anesthesiology specialists or by those who provide care to a greater number of children experience fewer adverse events.1–3 With such data in mind, the American College of Surgeons (ACS) has defined criteria to achieve optimal pediatric perioperative care. ACS criteria include a specific requirement that a specially trained pediatric anesthesiologist be available to provide care for all young children.4 Although this criterion is deemed optimal, it is widely recognized that a large number of facilities will remain unable to meet this benchmark, leaving many children to undergo surgery in less than ideal conditions. With the implementation of the ACS criteria for pediatric hospitals, pediatric anesthesiologists will need to implement novel approaches to expand the needed expertise to include a more diverse geographical location. The lack of ready access to pediatric anesthesiologists is well illustrated in the article by Muffly et al5 in this issue of the Journal. These investigators matched the most recent census data to pediatric anesthesiologist location data to estimate the distance children would have to travel to receive optimal service during surgery. Data from the study by Muffly et al5 demonstrate that more than 10 million children <17 years of age live >50 miles away from the nearest pediatric anesthesiologist location. Of greatest concern, nearly 3 million of the most vulnerable children (ie, those who are <4 years of age) would have to travel at ≥50 miles, and >500,000 would have to travel ≥100 miles, to obtain ideal anesthetic care. These data, in part, explain why 40% of all children undergo surgeries that include complex neonatal procedures in adult general hospital settings.6 Thus, many children across America remain at higher risk for perioperative complications. To optimize care, ACS suggests a 3-tiered children’s surgical care system wherein the highest tier (ie, level I center) meets the most stringent criteria and further provides overarching direction and leadership for a larger system that includes settings with less robust pediatric resources.4 To meet this imperative, it is incumbent upon level I centers to delineate the region and facilities that are within its purview and system. This important first step will enable level I centers to match the needs of children within their region with the capabilities and expertise of each facility. Furthermore, system delineation will be necessary to plan for and procure additional resources that may be needed given the potential increase in numbers of children triaged from nonspecialty facilities in the region to level I settings. The article by Muffly et al5 provides important data that can be used by level I centers to identify regions and areas in greatest need of system inclusion and outreach. Creative outreach strategies are needed to ensure that children, particularly those who are at greatest risk, have access to specialized expertise. ACS has acknowledged that key components of level I outreach include “dissemination of knowledge and expertise” and provision of access to educational programs.4 Conferences, visiting lectureships, and Web-based education may be used to enhance knowledge and increase awareness about the specialized perioperative needs of children. These strategies may be most useful to facilitate decision making and judgment about appropriate triage and transport. However, educational approaches have limited potential to improve the outcomes of children who must receive their care in low-volume settings either because of the urgency of need or resource limitations. Therefore, additional strategies are needed to enhance perioperative care for these children. The widespread availability of technology, Internet connectivity, and health information systems has expanded and enhanced our capability to improve access to pediatric specialists who are not physically present in remote communities. The potential value of teleconsultation was recently demonstrated in rural emergency departments in California, where consultation with pediatric critical care specialists led to a 4-fold decrease in medication errors in children.7 Pediatric anesthesiologists could utilize teleconsultation to assist with preoperative evaluation, triage, and care management on a case-by-case basis for children in remote areas. Furthermore, live videoconferencing could permit specialists to be actively involved in anesthesia monitoring and in directing the care of children during surgery.8 The potential benefits of pediatric “teleanesthesia” have been demonstrated by a team from Children’s Hospital of Philadelphia, which remotely directed the successful anesthetic care of 2 children undergoing liver transplantation in India.9 Teleanesthesia offers the possibility of expanding access to optimal anesthesia care across a region within a children’s surgical program. An important and notable limitation to effective telemedicine is the lack of reliable Internet connectivity and technical issues that have been described by other disciplines.10 Although reimbursement policies have provided a way to sustain basic health services in rural America, recruitment and retention of health providers remain an unmet challenge.11 Incentivizing specialists with student loan repayment or other motivators offers one strategy to improve access to specialists in underserved areas.12 However, such incentives are unlikely to expand services sufficiently to meet the needs of children in the remotest areas. Mobile medical and surgical teams have been extensively deployed to low-resource areas globally (eg, SmileTrain and Doctors Without Borders). Although these medical mission teams are widely and successfully utilized abroad, their use in rural America has not been well documented. Dentistry, routine health screening, and vaccination services have been provided by mobile teams dispatched to remote areas in America.13 Mobilizing multidisciplinary surgical teams to rural settings offers a creative solution to optimize care by bringing not only the pediatric anesthesiologist but also an entire team of specialists to the bedside in underserved areas. Such an approach might be considered when planning for the regionalization of children’s surgical services. Programs designed to expand specialty outreach must be evaluated for their cost, feasibility, reimbursement potential, professional liability, licensing concerns, and, importantly, their effect on children’s perioperative outcomes. Health care policy is urgently needed to ensure adequate resources to expand and implement outreach programs.11 Advocacy efforts from professional organizations such as the Society for Pediatric Anesthesia, ACS, American Academy of Pediatrics, and American Pediatric Surgical Association will be required to promote policy and secure the legal support and necessary resources. Finally, it will be critical that level I pediatric surgical centers work collaboratively to ensure that their regionalization efforts strategically incorporate all remote areas identified by the data from Muffly et al5. ACS and the data from Muffly et al5 emphasize the need for a multipronged outreach approach to ensure that we leave no child without access to the best anesthesia care possible. DISCLOSURES Name: Shobha Malviya, MD. Contribution: This author helped write the manuscript. Name: Terri Voepel-Lewis, PhD, RN. Contribution: This author helped write the manuscript. This manuscript was handled by: Nancy Borkowski, DBA, CPA, FACHE, FHFMA.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Malviya et al. (2017) conducted an editorial in Pediatric anesthesia. Millions of children in the United States live more than 50 miles from a pediatric anesthesiologist, highlighting the need for regionalized care, teleconsultation, and mobile surgical teams.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: