Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
The challenge of properly educating and preparing doctors for the 21st century is with us always. Traditionally we have focused on building understanding in the biopsycho-social sciences, competency in problem-solving, and skills in diagnosis, therapeutics and clinical management. With growing information that we are losing ground and/or making only the most minimal headway in achieving better health outcomes for the most economically depressed groups within our countries, it seems an appropriate time to reflect on the potential value of some new approaches. Medical schools must now be concerned in community action. Looking at causes of ‘premature’ death across the United States from a different perspective, McGinnis & Foege in 1993 came up with some shocking figures. Lifestyle issues related to social and behavioural causes were by far (at 51%) the largest reason for early death. Among these, the chief culprits were the use of tobacco and poor dietary/sedentary practices. Other factors included violent and abusive behaviours, the abuse of alcohol and other addictive substances, and unsafe sexual practices. It seems likely that among this cluster also lay the health ravages of poverty, ignorance, avarice and greed. Genetic anomalies and environmental causes accounted for about 20% each in their study, and lack of access to medical care for only about 10% of early deaths and disabilities. While the latter figure may need adjusting upward in the most underserved communities (in all countries, irrespective of their state of development), the evidence of the misdirection of our efforts in medical education has to be clear to all. Perhaps it isn't so much the content of our educational programmes that is remiss, but the context in which they are carried out. Because, even with our knowledge regarding the care of illness and even a better grasp of some solutions for the social and behavioural causes of poor health, there's little we as professionals can do to make long-term improvements unless there is an informed and engaged populace working in partnership with our efforts—a partnership that avoids the notorious twin traps of dependency and apathy. What kinds of improvements in medical education and training would allow us to put these rudimentary insights to greater use? First is a better understanding in our teaching staff and student bodies of the principles and goals of public health. Although public health has been called the ‘prevention’ specialty, and although we desperately need to implement broader clinical prevention strategies, the essence of a public health approach is the adoption of a ‘population’ perspective. More than just an understanding of how to keep individuals and families healthy and free from disease, doctors need to understand and adopt the principles of building health communities. Given the resources that are available, what's best to keep all or most of the people well? Health education, health promotion, disease prevention—all these are important for doctors to practice, and there's a time and place for each. Furthermore, doctors should be highly visible advocates for the health protectionist measures that sanitarians and environmentalists bring to our communities, and we need to speak out on issues of better access to quality health care for all people. Furthermore, we should be inspired to sort out and speak out for those health system reforms that can lead to a healthier populace. Fundamentally, however, doctors should know as much about the people they serve as about their bodies and their various diseases. All of us are members of a social order, and we live, work and play within circles of other individuals and groups. There is need, therefore, to understand communities and group behaviour, societal values and beliefs, as much as we understand human biology, but of course we don't. That's why we score so low in our performance with lifestyle issues. But that isn't the end of it. We don't have to do all these things personally. Other professionals are around, social workers and educators and legal/judiciary experts, and these can and will work with us to address the risks to personal health. Our job is to understand that this is part of a doctor's role, and that we are often called on as leaders to develop collegial approaches to community action. The most important part of our work in communities, however, has to be the capacity to work in partnerships with the people themselves. Effective partnerships begin with a level of trust, and this asset cannot be bought or demanded, it must be earned! Communities will never trust us, or we them, unless there is at least a modicum of mutual understanding and a measure of respect, of willingness to be co-equals in action. We talk commonly about community-oriented primary care and community-oriented prevention. True community partnerships require better than that. A community-oriented approach is an inherently professional one, usually top-down, one that's directed ‘to’ or ‘for’ community people. A community-based approach is better (not to mean community-placed, but community-responsive, community-driven, community-rooted). We as doctors should be working ‘with’ the community, rather than ‘for’ it and our graduates should learn the difference as a part of their basic training. So how does one teach ‘Community Organization and Development’, ‘Multicultural Competency’, and ‘Public Health’ concepts to tomorrow's doctors? By immersing a significant part of their education and training in some of the communities with the most severe health problems, and finding teaching staff who can work alongside them, who can understand and support the decision. Students need to live in the communities for a block of time to observe people in their daily lives and activities, and to get a better understanding of their habits and beliefs—healthy or unhealthy. Student doctors need to learn to teach the prevention of bacterial and parasitic diseases by knowing the fields, streams and factories where the people spend their time. They need to be in people's homes and kitchens, watching people acquire and prepare food, so that they can teach diabetic and cardiac patients how to avoid the complications of their disease. They need to understand why youth gangs are formed through observing the desolation and feelings of hopelessness of the street kids. They also need to grasp some of the strengths of the communities in which they will be working, since it is these assets that will become the foundation stones for progress. Most of all they need to understand and respect people in their own setting, regardless of their race, gender, age, creed or social class. The most difficult lesson for students in the health professions is to learn how to build working partnerships with community people to address unacceptable health risks. There must be a beginning grasp of the truth that all the best solutions to human problems grow out of local insights and approaches, that deficit-driven models usually don't work, and that the people who have the problem have to understand the nature of the problem and become a part of the planning for intervention. These are community development principles, rarely taught in medical school, but essential for future doctors. The most basic community development precept is that one ‘starts where the community is’, and ‘moves at its pace’. That ‘when outsiders begin an effort, it is important to turn the ownership over to the people as soon as possible’. And that ‘professionals can help inform and sustain community action, but rarely can achieve worth-while results working alone’. Medical teachers also have a great deal to gain from living, working and teaching in the community, and from getting to know something about community studies. Teaching staff increasingly will learn to understand the value and some of the limits of community service. They will learn that all the ‘experts’ are not in the institution, but that there are ‘experts’ on community and on societal health issues within the community itself. One of the greatest challenges about community health and its incorporation into the fabric of medical education is to persuade long-term faculty leaders that academic programmes in the community do not compromise the quality of learning, teaching, service and research. For too long now we have thought that only ‘barefoot’ doctors are trained in the community, whereas scientists and great intellectual leaders are trained in the classroom and laboratory. The truth is that both are needed, and either one without the other is deficient.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
T A Bruce (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: