Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Highlights value-based anesthesia topics; leaves open cardiovascular perioperative applications.
Value-Based Anesthesia Macario A, ed. Anesthesiology Clinics. Vol. 26, No. 4. Philadelphia: Saunders/Elsevier, 2008. ISBN-13: 978-1-4160-6273-8. 209 pages. $220.00 annual subscription for 4 issues. The neologism value-based anesthesia care was introduced in 19931 to encourage anesthesiologists to look beyond widely misunderstood concepts (e.g., cost-effectiveness), to focus on meeting the challenge of enhancing the value of anesthesia care by providing the best patient outcome achievable at reasonable cost. Meanwhile, usage in anesthesiology and business2 has evolved to include using documented clinical results (e.g., observational data sets) to direct efforts to improve the efficiency and quality of care. The current international economic crisis adds urgency to achieving the greatest value from societal investments in clinical care, particularly in the United States, where it is now well documented that our standings on health indices are generally mediocre, yet we spend up to 50% more per capita on health care than other developed countries around the world. Thus, it is most timely that Alex Macario, one of the leading figures in this field, has recruited 16 international authors, mostly clinical anesthesiologists based at academic medical centers, to join him in surveying diverse facets of value-based anesthesia care. Many of the 11 articles develop the value proposition, albeit in varying degree, covering a very wide range of topics, including comprehensive anesthesia information management systems, development of efficient regional anesthesia programs, improving clinical communication, evaluating new technology, enhancing operating room management, measuring patient satisfaction with anesthesia care, and societal correlates (e.g., cost, quality, safety) of part-time clinical careers. Others articles treating equally diverse turf - international (U.S. and European) perspectives on anesthesiologist workforce supply, international perceptions (U.S. and Australian) of part-time anesthesiology training and careers, increasing role of in-licensing in pharmaceutical product development, and interactions among technology innovators, manufacturers, and purchasers - are so loosely (if at all) tethered to the value proposition that one wonders whether they belong in the same volume, or perhaps whether a broader title (e.g., management science, anesthesia care delivery) might better reflect the book’s diverse contents. Among my favorite articles are those on patient satisfaction assessment, clinical information systems, regional anesthesia programs, and enhanced clinical communication. The patient satisfaction article describes the thorny methodologic issues in measuring what most believe (incorrectly) is wholly subjective and unrelated to quality of care, provides a scholarly review of prior efforts and particularly what factors (many modifiable) have been shown to influence the patient’s assessment of anesthesia care, and then sets forth strategies (all involving enhanced communication) to improve patient satisfaction. The article on information systems provides a similar, literature-based treatment, largely a review of the many benefits of such systems (e.g., improved staff scheduling, reduced drug and staffing costs, increased anesthesia charge capture, enhanced patient safety, observation data sets for clinical studies and improvement work), although with minimal guidance on the cost and management issues. Although the value of regional anesthesia as an anesthetic technique and/or pain management adjunct is well established, this article provides guidance on how to develop a program fostering the efficient and effective delivery of regional anesthesia. With poor communication among the most prevalent root causes of sentinel events, the clinical communication article provides a well documented business case, as well as the risk management basis, for enhancing communication among all clinicians involved in anesthesia and surgery. Regardless of whether all of the articles truly belong in this volume, each article is a scholarly, comprehensive, well illustrated and documented, current treatment of its topic and is surprisingly well indexed. Unfortunately, in what is possibly a reflection of the lead-time in producing the volume, the article on the anesthesiology workforce supply presents a hackneyed “shortage” perspective which the current economic downturn is treating with a substantial decrease in demand for discretionary care. Even before the economy recovers, long overdue health insurance reform is seen as an integral part of restoring U.S. economic growth, because the growth in our health care expenditures now broaches a near-term unsustainable situation for governmental entities, private industry, and the general public. The legislative debate is only resuming now, but such reform is likely to moderate procedure utilization rates (at least in geographic areas with demonstrably high rates) in the U.S. Overall, this volume places current thinking about value-based anesthesia care in one convenient place. What began almost 20 years ago as an academic intellectual exercise has developed into an evolving body of practical knowledge that will hopefully guide us in achieving greater value in anesthesia care in the future. Fredrick K. Orkin, MD, MBA, SM Adjunct Professor of Anesthesiology Yale University School of Medicine New Haven, CT [email protected]
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Fredrick K. Orkin (2009) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: