Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
An editorial discussing the complexities and political sensitivities of publishing a manuscript comparing the outcomes and costs of physician anesthesiologists versus certified registered nurse anesthetists.
The goal of health care reform is to ensure the best possible care at the lowest cost. Achieving this goal requires that we change the delivery of both general and specialty care. Change in anesthesia is particularly challenging and complex because we have both physician and nonphysician providers. A widespread assumption is that nonphysician anesthetists (e.g., certified registered nurse anesthetists [CRNAs]) provide similar quality care at a lower cost than do physician anesthesiologists. But a comparison of the scope of physician and CRNA practice and expertise makes this assumption difficult to confirm. Moreover, the disparity in remuneration between anesthesiologists and CRNAs is decreasing in many areas of the country as new payment policies are developed to streamline costs. Putting cost aside, how do physicians and CRNAs differ, if at all, in their effects on patient safety and outcome? Although relatively straightforward, this question is difficult to answer because outcome data in anesthesia are limited. Excluding adverse outcomes specific to technique (e.g., intubation of the esophagus), poor outcomes in complicated patients frequently have multiple causes, making the contribution of anesthesia per se difficult to quantify. Advances in anesthetic technique (e.g., transesophageal echocardiography, deliberate hypotension, hemodilution) that could improve outcome from complicated surgical procedures can require high-level clinical decision making, not just skilled delivery of care, and thus usually warrant an anesthesiologist. Clearly, a number of difficult and delicate issues must be addressed before we can define optimal anesthesia care at the lowest cost. Unfortunately, when the data addressing important questions are limited, politics often influence perception. This is certainly the case in anesthesia care delivery. The purpose of our journal, Anesthesia & Analgesia, is to publish manuscripts advancing anesthesia care and knowledge. We have tried to avoid political issues. Thus, my initial response was to choose the "safe" decision and reject for publication the manuscript "Anesthesia Providers, Patient Outcomes, and Costs" by Abenstein and Warner which appears in this issue of our journal [1]. This manuscript is the report of a study initially undertaken to respond to the request of the Minnesota legislature to evaluate anesthesia practices relative to patient outcomes and health care costs. There were many reasons not to publish this paper. First, as recognized by Abenstein and Warner, "[it] lacks the scientific credibility of a review or original article and is related to policy making more than science." However, our Editorial Board reasoned that outcome and cost-benefit studies are desperately needed. Second, Abenstein and Warner often are not only subjective, but clearly biased toward one method of anesthesia care delivery. However, we felt that they had made an acceptable effort to analyze the available limited data. Additionally, they are both practitioners at the Mayo Clinic, which has a long history of excellence in the training of both physician anesthesiologists and CRNAs, thereby qualifying them more than most to conduct such an analysis. Presumably, their teaching and clinical experience provide them an especially good prospective on physician and CRNA practice examined both separately and together. Third, some of the information they provide, especially the comparison of training requirements for physician anesthesiologists and CRNAs, is already known by most of our readers. Nonetheless, we felt that this paper might offer a model to other health care funding agencies who could benefit from such an analysis. Finally, because Anesthesia & Analgesia is an international journal, we questioned whether we should publish a study addressing an issue that seems so specifically American. However, our international reviewers expressed as much interest in this paper as their American counterparts, reflecting, perhaps, the almost universal problem of funding present health care systems. On balance, therefore, following an intensive peer review process (nine reviewers and multiple revisions) and cognizant of existing limitations, we felt that the publication of this paper could contribute meaningfully to the literature. To add further perspective, we asked Duane Rorie, MD, Chairman of the Department of Anesthesia at Mayo Clinic, and Francis James, MD, Chairman of Anesthesia at Bowman Gray School of Medicine and a Director on the American Board of Anesthesiology, to write editorials which follow [2,3]. Both have extensive experience with both physician anesthesiologists and CRNAs as care providers. Clearly, we need to develop the methodology to compare objectively the quality and costs of different models of anesthesia delivery. We hope this paper provides an initial model that can serve future analyses of anesthesia care delivery.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Ronald D. Miller (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: