Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
This letter critiques a previous study on the cost-effectiveness of physician anesthesia, advocating for a more comprehensive cost analysis comparing CRNAs and physicians.
To the Editor: As a CRNA currently working in a team anesthesia setting, I feel obliged to write regarding “Is Physician Anesthesia Cost Effective?” (1) This is the most recent attempt to prove anesthesia outcomes by quoting outdated studies (2,3) with significant limitations. By basing their findings on an obsolete study on perioperative mortality, and stating a 600% increase in anesthesiologists as the reason that patient outcomes have dramatically improved, the authors disregard the advancements made both in pharmacology and monitoring. The elegant 2003 study of surgical mortality and type of anesthesia provider by Pine et al. (4) found similar risk-adjusted mortality rates between hospitals without anesthesiologists and hospitals where anesthesiologists provided or directed care. This study also has double the amount of participants than the studies quoted by Abenstein et al (1). Abenstein et al. stated that anesthesia conversion factors are the same for CRNAs and physicians. If that is true, and differences in mortality cannot be shown, then it should be a simple matter to prove true cost-effectiveness. The study should include salary, cost of office space, support staff, computers, business trips, and benefits. If one compared the true cost per hour versus the amount of revenue generated, one would surely see which anesthesia model is most cost-effective. Marilyn Weis, MNA, CRNA Department of Anesthesiology Mayo Clinic Rochester, MN [email protected]
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Marilyn Weis (2004) conducted a letter in Anesthesia outcomes and cost-effectiveness. Anesthesia provider type (CRNA vs Physician) was evaluated.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: