Key points are not available for this paper at this time.
Design
Editorial
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
A letter to the editor critiquing a previous article's claims regarding nurse anesthesia education, accreditation, and the relationship between provider type and patient outcomes.
To the Editor: I recently received the current copy of Anesthesia & Analgesia and, after reading the editorial regarding "Anesthesia Providers, Patient Outcome," was anxious to read the article. I have had a great deal of respect for the publication and as indicated by your editorial was relieved to hear that this was not meant to be another piece of political rhetoric meant to besmirch one practitioner or another. Finally, we would have a comprehensive piece of literature that would factually and scientifically analyze the issues and present them in a nonpartisan manner. Unfortunately, from a purely factual perspective the article is fraught with discrepancies. In regard to nurse anesthesia education, the educational component does not usually last two years; it lasts a minimum of two years with the vast majority of programs being 27 months or longer. Nurse anesthesia students are required to rotate through all specialties, not most as indicated by the article. The programs are and have been held to strict standards regarding student clinical case requirements-a standard that has just recently found its way into resident educational requirements. Nurse anesthetists may not elect to take the National Certification Examination, if they would like to be employed in any of the 50 states, unlike resident physicians. In regard to the issue of accreditation, the Council on Accreditation of Nurse Anesthesia Educational Programs (COA) is an independent entity that is recognized by the United States Department of Education (USDE). It is not controlled by or regulated by the American Association of Nurse Anesthetists. Standards that are established are promulgated by USDE requirements and the COA, which not only has representation from nurse anesthesia educators, university academicians, and hospital administrators, but also includes an anesthesiologist. The certifying body, the Council on Certification, similar to the COA, is an independent entity that is directly responsible for the certification mechanism for Certified Registered Nurse Anesthetists, which I might add is a requirement, not an option! The two councils, along with the Council on Public Interest, which provides checks and balances, are strictly independent. Much like resident education, this prevents inappropriate influences of any one governing body over the other. As a director of a school of nurse anesthesia and a representative on the Council on Accreditation, I also take issue with the statement regarding student activities being confined to the operating room. Anesthesia students rotate through pain management, neonatal intensive care unit (in many institutions), postanesthesia care unit, and respiratory care services. Nurse anesthesia students are required to see all of their patients pre- and postoperatively and to discuss the anesthetic management with the patient. Regarding the number of providers, the authors again made spurious assumptions about some of the reasons for the decline in nurse anesthesia students. In the 1970s, closure of many programs was due to restriction of clinical sites for nurse anesthesia clinical training by anesthesiologist and also increased educational standards and requirements. The result is that the remaining programs are of a very high caliber and they educate nurse anesthesia students who are proficient and capable of assuming their role within the practice of anesthesia. From a strictly analytical perspective, I found it interesting how the authors were able to arrive at a definitive conclusion based on the results of several mortality studies when no other author was able to make the same conclusion. They did concede that the cause for improvement in outcomes is problematic; however, they then made a quantum leap in the conclusion from their review of the literature that the cause of improved outcomes was the increase in physician anesthesia providers. This conclusion was based on 20-year-old data from a limited number of observations. There are similar articles that have skewed results to prove political points which have reported varying conclusions from the same studies. I would have expected more rigor in a publication that was primarily research based such as Anesthesia & Analgesia. Kathleen Hanna, CRNA, EdD School of Nurse Anesthesia Pennsylvania Hospital Philadelphia, PA 19107-6192
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Kathleen Hanna (1996) studied this question.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: