Key result
Mechanical prostheses were associated with a lower risk of thromboembolism but increased bleeding compared to bioprostheses.
Why the study?
Does a biological prosthesis compared to a mechanical prosthesis affect survival and valve-related morbidity in patients undergoing valve replacement?
Cohort (n=3,279)
Yes
Does a biological prosthesis compared to a mechanical prosthesis affect survival and valve-related morbidity in patients undergoing valve replacement?
In patients undergoing valve replacement, mechanical prostheses are associated with better survival in those <70 years and lower thromboembolism risk, but higher bleeding risk compared to bioprostheses.
Answers are grounded in this paper and cite their sources.
Mechanical valves link to lower thromboembolism but higher bleeding; leaves optimal prosthesis selection open pending randomized data.
OBJECTIVES: To compare valve-related morbidity among patients aged < 70 and ≥ 70 years, receiving either a mechanical or a biological prosthesis in a population-based setting. DESIGN: In total, 3279 patients (21 644 patient-years) were followed up through the Swedish National In-Patients Register, which registers all hospital admissions. Death, thromboembolism, bleeding, endocarditis, valve thrombosis and reoperations were all captured. RESULTS: Survival was lower among patients aged <70 years with a bioprosthesis compared to a mechanical prosthesis (p < 0.0001), but equal among older patients. A mechanical prosthesis indicated a lower risk (p < 0.001) of thromboembolism (1.5% per patient year, ppy), than bioprosthesis (2.6% ppy), irrespective of age. Bleeding was increased (p = 0.002) with a mechanical prosthesis (1.7% ppy) compared to a bioprosthesis (1.1% ppy); the risk of bleeding increased early (<5 years) whereas thromboembolism increased late (>5 years). Event-free survival was higher in younger patients with a mechanical prosthesis compared to bioprosthesis recipients (p < 0.001), but equal among older patients. CONCLUSIONS: Survival was comparable in older patients irrespective of prosthesis type. Bleeding was increased with a mechanical prosthesis, especially in the elderly. The risk of thromboembolism was higher in patients with a bioprosthesis.
No takes yet. Share an insight, caveat, or question.
Hellgren et al. (2011) conducted a cohort in Valve replacement (n=3,279). Mechanical prosthesis vs. Biological prosthesis was evaluated on Thromboembolism (p=<0.001). Mechanical prostheses were associated with a lower risk of thromboembolism but increased bleeding compared to bioprostheses.
Synapse has enriched 10 related papers. Consider them for comparative context: